Chapter Six

ROXIE

I woke up feeling like I’d been in a deep sleep. I tried to move, but quickly realized I couldn’t. I wasn’t alone and this wasn’t my bed.

My head was resting on a soft breast, my body pressed against hers, our legs tangled together. Nari had her arms wrapped around my waist and Kai’s arms were wrapped around her.

I guess the surprise threesome had worn us all out. Kai was even snoring a little, which was kind of cute. I tried not to giggle so I wouldn’t wake them.

The night had been unexpected, but that didn’t stop us from going two rounds. I never would have expected this from them.

I carefully wiggled out from Nari’s hold, trying not to wake them. I looked around for my scattered clothes, which seemed to be everywhere.

I decided to skip the panties and bra and just put on my uniform to save time since I couldn’t find them in the dark.

As I bent over to put on my sneakers, I heard a hum of approval that startled me. Nari was awake and she was enjoying the view of me getting dressed.

I turned around and winked at her; despite how unexpected it was, last night with them had been amazing. She licked her lips like she was ready for more.

“Don’t get any ideas. You had your taste. Tutoring is over. I’ll see you two tomorrow,” I whispered.

“I have a feeling one day you’re not going to want to sneak out on us. You’ll want to be ours.”

She smiled shyly and then cuddled back into Kai. I was glad because she didn’t see the shock on my face.

I hurried out of the house and practically threw myself into my car. ~WHAT THE FUCK WAS THAT?!~ I thought as my mind finally caught up with everything.

I let out a breath I didn’t know I was holding and looked back at the house. I checked the time. Damn, it was midnight.

I’d been there for hours and just had the best sex of my life with a couple from my school I barely spoke to. Nari and I usually didn’t even exchange more than an eye roll.

But the fact that she and her boyfriend had just made me cum more times than I could count might make school a little awkward tomorrow.

As I drove home, my mind started to wander and my pussy started to throb again. What did she mean I’d be theirs? My pussy ached at that thought. But this was blackmail…right?

But if I was being honest, did they even need to blackmail me at this point? After that, I would willingly ride Nari’s face and/or Kai’s dick daily if given the chance.

I’d never been with anyone so focused on my pleasure, let alone two people. Could they really like me more than just for sex? Or was I actually losing my mind?

My mind was racing so it was probably the second option. Damn, the sex was hot. I’d never been with a girl all the way.

The only other time was four years ago when I let Nari feel me up in her basement closet while I sucked on her neck and groped her ass. Our bodies fit together so perfectly that night.

We were both super into it, but when someone called a one-minute warning we pushed each other away and couldn’t look each other in the eye.

I didn’t even know what to say. I was super confused because I’d never felt like that before with a girl.

After the incident, she hooked up with Kai as far as I knew, and we never spoke again. That was until today in her room because of that damn Mrs. Joseph.

Not that we did much talking tonight. The way she touched my body could only be described as magical. It was like she’d touched me before and knew just how to make me cum.

I squeezed my legs together again. Damn, I was wet all over again thinking of how the night started. When Kai came in, it only kicked things up.

I didn’t expect him to take control the way he did, but I loved every second of it. Maybe I should have taken Nari up on another round; I didn’t know if I could wait till next week to have them again.

I parked the car and fixed my clothes a little, trying not to look like I’d just been fucked. I didn’t want the neighbors to see me looking a mess. I knew there wasn’t anyone in my own big house.

Everyone thought my parents were always on vacation and parented by way of telephone and video chat. That story was fine by me; it allowed me to live my life how I saw fit.

I didn’t plan on correcting anyone. ~I could easily live a life here with a boyfriend and girlfriend and no one would know~, I thought as I entered the house.

What the hell was I thinking?! Boyfriend and girlfriend? I needed to stay focused on just getting this paper signed, graduating on my cheer scholarship, and getting the hell out of here.

I couldn’t get mixed up in feelings. I had to stick to the plan. Getting out of New Hampshire was my only goal.

My phone beeped a couple times as I got in the shower, and I decided to ignore it until I got out. It was probably my so-called mother checking in.

She ~would~ check in with her eighteen-year-old daughter in the middle of the night. But I needed this time to think.

Why did I like what they did to me so much? Nari’s boldness calmed me somehow, and I gave in to her every demand. That had never happened before.

We were both out of character, you could say, and it was amazing. It felt good to give up control for a little while, and for it to end in that amount of pleasure was mind-blowing.

I didn’t have to think for once and just felt.

After a long shower, I reluctantly checked my phone. My body was ready for the comfort of my bed. My body was thoroughly satisfied, but it needed sleep.

Shit! My eyes went wide when I opened the text. It was a group chat from the horny couple who’d just fucked me. I squeezed my legs together, a whole new puddle forming in my panties.

How?! How could I be getting worked up again? It was just a text from Kai. ~I’ve done this flirting thing with a ton of guys, relax~, I told myself.

But it was different. I’d never flirted with a girl and her boyfriend simultaneously in a group chat, especially not after they’d had their way with me.

Kai

Tutoring session #1 signed off princess. Great session.

Nari

can’t wait for the next one. This Saturday sound good?

Roxie

you two are enjoying this huh? Why are you blackmailing me? 🙄

Kai

you seemed to be enjoying yourself . Is it really blackmail if your enjoying it?

Nari

you did enjoy it right?

What was I supposed to say to that? My phone buzzed again. It didn’t feel like coercion, not after the second climax. My body had craved it, and I wasn’t afraid to admit that.

Kai

so ?

Nari

did you like it?

Nari

Was your pussy still wet when you left ? Do you want more?

Kai

Be honest with us and yourself princess. It can only get better between us three.

I didn’t have to ponder my response because, deep down, I already knew. I craved more. If he could guarantee something even better than what we’d just experienced, I was all in. It seemed like a win-win situation.

They could keep me satisfied until I graduated college, which would be a welcome distraction from this life that everyone else thought was so wonderful but felt so lonely to me.

Besides, I’d still graduate on time, and it was a sure bet they’d get Mrs. Joseph off my case.

Roxie

yes I want more…yes my pussy is still wet for you both

Nari

😊. I like to hear that.

Roxie

Can we talk more tomorrow? I’m exhausted and have practice in the morning. You two can come here to my place after practice after school.

Kai

see you at 7?

Roxie

🎯

My phone buzzed again, the screen illuminating with a call from my mom. Screw her—I didn’t want her to ruin my good mood. I had to be up at five in the morning, so I settled in for the night. Eventually, I drifted off, worn out from the day’s events.