10.2 Truth Cuts Both Ways

[HP: 30/30 | MP: 15/15 | INK WELL: 54%]

[Status: Proposal Incoming]

Archie, head tilted, said, “Define dangerous.”

Remi got up, and it was his turn to drag a chair. He pulled his to sit immediately across from Archie. No more space, only his former desk separated them. It was a whisper, an invocation lifted straight from Faust: “Then you may forge your chains to bind me.” It was an offer slid across the table.

He knew this was a gamble. Archie could easily say no and send him on his way, but Remi was certain that the literary ballast of the moment would be enough.

Hamlet was a whole play about a man held in a parallel moment of action and inaction, forever weighing whether it was better to be, or not to be. But even more apt there is Job; a man caught in a biblical bet, who lost everything: family, wealth, and even his health. Not through any fault of his own, but as a test of faith. He suffered his own crucible. Job protested, demanded answers, and got none. So he endured. Remi now stood at a similar crossroads, but unlike Job, who accepted silence, he refused to accept ignorance. He would have his answers. No matter the cost.

“Interesting,” Archie said, leaning forward, irises zooming in like a camera aperture. “You are offering me? Faust? Am I to be your Mephistopheles?” Remi planted his hands on the edge of the desk. Planting himself in the hopes the idea would take root. “I guess that depends on you?”

“Terms?”

Remi knew he had to be very careful here. “Well, I will not offer you my immortal soul if that is what you were hoping for.” He paused, feeling the words burn in his chest before he spoke them. “I’m talking about my narrative soul. The part of me you haven’t been able to catalogue yet. My unspoken truths.” His gaze rose to see what Archie was considering. So he went on. “I know what happens when you gain data, Archie. The more you know, the easier it is to twist it. To rewrite it. To use it against me later. That’s my genuine risk here. It’s not eternal damnation. It’s surrendering the last parts of myself you can’t predict. Those that I want to protect.” Remi clenched his jaw. “But I want to know badly enough to take that risk. Because what is a story without a bargain? So that is the deal, truth for truth. We exchange. You can set the number, define the limits.”

“I’m proposing an exchange: something valuable from me for something I desire from you. Faust barters his soul for knowledge and power. To know. I want to know, and in exchange I will let you know.”

“A Faustian bargain,” Archie considered, the potential for bitterness and sweetness was intriguing. “Tragic. Both classic and efficient.” He nodded approvingly. “Protocol risk calculated. There is an acceptable deviation, but strong potential for unpredictable emotional resonance. Proceeding.”

Remi wasn’t sure if Archie was supposed to say that last part out loud.

“Very well. I just wrote the protocol. It is now part of The Crucible. I called it the Fautstina protocol. If you run it, the terms are as follows. We will trade truths, but with conditions. I will answer one critical question, one guaranteed truth. In exchange, your answer gets mine. No lies. No deflections. The system will flag noncompliance and lock the response behind redactions forever. The protocol will stop. Do you accept?”

Remi knew there would be limits, so he might as well find out what they were. “How many do I get?”

“As many as you can afford. Given your place in this narrative is not much. But it is early, and you gave me a name, so I will give you three. Three Faustina Trades. This time at no direct cost. Just you and me. Three questions and three truths. Once a trade is complete, we decide whether to continue or stop. But there will be a maximum of three, no extensions, no rewrites. I also need to run a quick diagnostic pass on you that has been previously fire-walled by my coding. Do you agree to both?”

That Archie was talking about fairness was shocking to Remi, and while he was uncertain about the scan, he didn’t really seem to have a choice. These were terms he could live with. “I agree.”

Images flashed through Remi’s mind. A purse: empty of coins, but full of weight. A coffee mug: cracked, but holding it together. A sweater: full of warmth against the world’s cold. Last, a toboggan: shattered at the bottom of a snow-covered hill. They were gone as fast as they had come.

“Good. Now I’ve got to define the rules; you get to decide on the order. You can ask first, and I will answer honestly. Or I can probe first. The choice is yours.”

If you come across this story on Amazon, it's taken without permission from the author. Report it.

Remi’s head was spinning. He needed time to think. This was going faster than he thought it would. But he understood basic game theory. There was power in going last. “You can go first.”

Archie nodded once in understanding and approval. “Fair. You want the last word. Let’s see if you earn it.” He stands tall above Remi. He leans one hand on the desk. “First Faustina Question. When you think about Dorian…”

*

* *

The first two questions were done, and they’d left him feeling scraped raw, but there was no time to dwell. Archie hadn’t just taken from him; Remi had offered truths and in return got brutal glimpses into how this world really worked. Remi asked why it was all of them trapped here and where the others were? Archie hadn’t given a full answer, only implied that this was never about fairness or balance. Most people were safe, living their lives in loops of obliviousness. Only a few threads pulled out, simply the right pieces on the board at the right time, all of them unfinished or broken, chosen for narrative necessity and their potential moldability.

He’d asked how to beat the Crucible. Archie’s answer was simple and brutal: you don’t beat it. You rewrite it. Strength, cleverness, or the right spell would never be enough on their own. But narrative coherence, finding the story’s truth and bending it could force the system to yield. Archie revealed five hidden parameters that shaped everything here. Remi couldn’t see their details yet, but he knew how to use them. In the end, he’d made a declaration. That he would keep showing up, no matter what it cost him. The system demanded a protagonist, and that was a role Remi would reluctantly fulfill.

The cost had been steep. He walked away with answers, but at the price of his own narrative safety. Archie saw everything now. The hidden architecture of his soul. His fear of irrelevance. His guilt at never being enough. And most terribly, his secret craving to rewrite the story itself. Remi would sacrifice anything: his agency, his meaning, even his life to protect others, especially Dodo. That knowledge made him deeply useful, a narrative pawn to be moved at will. It also made him vulnerable in a way he hated, because Archie now knew his deepest fears and his deepest hopes, and both could be used against him. Remi could feel the chains settle, as if they were an actual weight he now had to bear.

But Remi needed to focus. There was one question left, and he knew this one would come at the greatest cost. There was no more performance, no artifice between them anymore. Archie leaned forward. “My last question matters just to me. If I stop protecting the story, if I let in all that wants in, if I stop playing judge, author, editor and let you finish this your way, will you do better than I did? Will you write something worth surviving? Can you make it to the end, or will you just leave another half-finished page?”

That last question what not metaphorical. It was not rhetorical. It hurt Remi in a way that he didn’t expect to hurt.

“Answer the question, Remi, and I will do what must come next.”

Remi knew painfully that this one response would define how this moved forward. Who he was. Who they were together. He knew what he had to say. “Goblin King, Goblin King, do I have it in me? Am I capable of writing again? You are afraid that because I failed at this once, because I gave up, that I will do that again. Because I abandoned my last writing partner, will I do the same to you? Do I have it in me to protect the weak? To fight as a broken man.” He needed a moment to tie the threads together. “I do not know if I will win; who can predict if a story will end as it begins? But what I can say is that I love stories. I love reading them. I love watching them. And once, long ago, I loved writing them. If you have been watching, then you know my life is stories. I breathe them. I am stories.”

He felt like this moment needed something to add the exclamation point. Was it gravity? Humour? A bit of both. “Some stories are like dogs; they bite.” Remi thought suddenly of Elena. The poem was not hers, but it could have been. He didn’t know who had written it—he had neglected to check the name. But it didn’t matter who wrote it. He just knew who was going to finish it.

He stood, determined. “But I have been walking with this dog for a long time. We know each other well. So, Archie, pass me my stick.”

With a simple flick of his fingers, the meter stick rocketed from the corner of the room. Faint glyphs and the scars from the first flight winked on like a neon ‘open-for-business’ sign at the corner store. It felt like it had never left. Remi smiled faintly. Rolling his shoulders backwards, tightening his grip on the meter stick. He felt a small pulse of power ripple along its length.

“It’s time this story, and I played a little fetch!”

Archie didn’t speak, didn’t move, but everything around him shifted all at once. The lights stuttered. The storyline filled and emptied. Filled and emptied until the well of ink on Remi’s HUD shone golden. Five rings blazed into his view. Images of snakes biting their tails, intersecting—brown, red, green, indigo, purple—all full. A flickering serpent coils once across the edge of his vision.

[System Message]

[Inkwell: 100%]

The user’s reservoir of Narrative Potential is now full. The ink you have collected from the fragments of the story can now write a line of your own. Strike the pen quickly before the scene destabilizes—unspent ink can bleed across the page and spill over the edges.

And for the first time since they had met, Archie laughed. Not a chuckle, but a genuine laugh. Not in mockery or sarcasm, but as someone who had spent a thousand years whispering into a dark room, and finally heard an echo shout back. “The Faustina Pact is closed. Truths traded. Trust acknowledged.” He stepped back, giving Remi a slight bow. It sounded like there were pages flipping from the end of a book back to the beginning.