A Second First

MADISON

~Try me.~

As soon as the words rolled off her tongue, Ethan was on her again, his hands on her lower back and his hard sex against her bare ass.

“Good God…be careful what you ask for, ’Flake,” Levi growled beneath her. Reaching for her neck with one hand, he pulled her closer, devouring her lips.

“I need you to relax,” Ethan said as his already wet tip rubbed between her ass cheeks. The contact of her skin with his manhood had both of them gasping.

“I’ll go slow. I’ll be gentle. But please don’t move, love…”

With one hand on her lower back and one hand at the base of his sex, he guided himself until his tip was rubbing against her wet folds, then moved up to her second, secret hole.

His strokes were long and slow, and he went all the way down to one then came back all the way up.

It wasn’t weird. In fact, she could feel both of their soft tips lightly touching her wet folds, rubbing against her.

She moaned against Levi’s lips as his tip teased one hole and Ethan’s did the same to her other.

Although Levi pulled back, rubbing his tip against her clit, Ethan pushed slowly against her second entrance.

His finger was nothing compared to his tip, and her body stiffened.

“Are you sure you want to skip the toy? It’ll help you.”

“The only thing I want inside me is you.” An animalistic growl left her lips. “The toy can wait.”

Slapping her ass lightly, Ethan went back to his teasing, letting his tip ease his way into her tight, tight ass.

“Breathe, my love, and relax,” he whispered as his tip managed to push its way in, but only a little before he pulled back.

“I…I…uhhhmmm,” she groaned, closing her eyes as Ethan’s tip again eased its way in, although this time he pushed a little more inside and she could feel her walls stretch more against his sex.

A hiss of pain ran through her body, and her breath caught. Ethan froze, and the moment she relaxed again, gasping for air, he pulled away.

“You okay, ’Flake?” he asked, now massaging her lower back, keeping his sex between her warm cheeks.

“Mm…yes,” she breathed out, sinking her nails into Levi’s shoulder.

“You don’t know what you do to us, do you?” Levi’s voice was lower and hoarser than usual, and his eyes a much darker shade.

“Maybe you should…show me…” Her words cut through her panting breaths, and the small chuckle coming from behind her only made her squirm more.

Ethan didn’t say anything, and his silence only served to keep her focused on his movements.

In fact, with her walls clenching hard in anticipation, she released a relieved breath when his sex finally prodded her entrance again.

But this time it wasn’t just a slow in and out.

This time she could feel Ethan’s body tense as his hips pushed forward.

ETHAN

His tip found its way in with less resistance this time, but still not too easily. And when the whole tip was in, he stayed still, listening to her sweet noises and curses.

He gave her time to accept his sex, and the moment her body and her walls relaxed around him enough, he slowly pushed in one more inch. Thanks to how wet she was, there was no need to lubricate more.

“Mmm…ohhh…Ethan,” she moaned.

“Jesus Christ, Madison. Fuck,” he cursed through his teeth. “Are you okay?” he asked again, short of breath.

“Yes…I… Jesus, it feels…good,” she managed to let out as he pulled out before easing his way in again.

He teased her like that for a while, helping her relax.

When her noises became murmurs of pleasure, he pushed in a little bit more, giving her a chance to feel, inch by inch, his whole manhood.

“God…Ethan!” she screamed and pushed her ass back against him.

He was now buried fully inside her, and she let out a small cry of pain.

“I told you, don’t move,” he gritted out as his breath died once more in his throat. ~Jesus~, she was clenching her walls around him.

They both stayed absolutely still for a moment, breathing hard. And then—

“I’m ready,” she whispered, moving her hips just a little.

“Mmm…’Flake,” he groaned before slowly, carefully starting to move his hips backward and forward, thrusting in and out of her in small yet precise strokes.

MADISON

As Ethan’s thrusts gained in speed, Levi slid his finger up and down Madison’s sleek folds, torturing her clit before moving down to tease her entrance.

But when Levi eased two of his fingers inside her from the front, Madison’s eyes opened wide.

She moved one of her hands from his shoulder down to his sex.

“What are you doing?” Levi asked.

“I said…I’m ready.”

Ethan immediately stopped his movements, still deep inside her.

“If it’s too much, tell us,” Levi whispered, pulling her closer only to bite on her lips softly.

“God, I love you,” she said, and he slowly guided his twitching sex to her entrance. Slowly but firmly, he eased his way in just as his brother had.

Closing her eyes, Madison let the boys take full control of her body, which was on fire. Her muscles were in pain, and her inner muscles were all stretched out.

But despite the discomfort, the buildup in her lower abdomen was one hundred times stronger, and she could feel her lower region burning with pleasure too.

Nothing had ever felt so good, and nothing had ever felt so right.

The way the two boys moved in and out of her, following each other’s rhythm, was just unbelievable, and she couldn’t stop thinking about how lucky she was.

They knew what to say and when, and mostly they knew how and where to touch her.

Like now, when they were both inside her, seeming to have discovered new unthinkable places, the spots that they managed to reach only making her cry out for more.

But it had been a long, teasing session for all of them, and now all that could be heard, apart from flesh slapping flesh, were their uneven and short breaths.

The more they thrust in and out of her, the more the world seemed to slow down.

“God…hmm…ohhh…I…I…” Short of words, her body spoke for her.

Ethan and Levi thrust just a bit harder inside her, and, as if moved by a shock of electricity, her muscles started to shake, forcing her to bite down on her lip as her body spasmed.

The pool of juices running down her legs was just as instantaneous as before, and judging by the loud growls coming from both her men, their fluids were mixed in.

“Fuuuuck,” they both groaned as their orgasms took over.

They keep thrusting in and out of her for a little while before Ethan pulled out of her first, collapsing onto the couch next to her and Levi.

Levi followed a short time after, letting Madison roll to the side, toward his brother.

She nestled between her two men, and they wrapped their limbs around her. Their scents were so mixed that it was difficult to distinguish who was who, and she was already so tangled up in them that the three of them looked like one.

A big smile spread across her face as the answer to their unspoken question.

“I love you. That was…”

“Amazing?” Levi whispered, squeezing her waist.

~Yes, we are definitely made for each other.~ “Mmm. I would say the best time so far.”

The sly look she gave them made Ethan growl, and when he swooped in for a kiss, she put a momentary finger on his lips.

“Thank you for making my second first time…so incredibly good.”

And then her lips crashed into his.