Play, Part One

MADISON

Madison rolled her eyes.

“Ezra, you know that you ~are~ one of those guys, right? You should give me some credit. I’ve learned a lot from the four of you, and I can take care of myself.”

“She has a point,” Ethan said, shrugging his shoulders; the intensity of his gaze on her body, however, had a million unspoken words in it.

The way he and Levi were staring at her made her thighs clench. She knew they were eye-fucking her, but hopefully it just read angry and overprotective to her brothers.

“Well, since we’re all going out, why don’t we just go together?” Liam suggested.

“Let’s go then.” Ezra walked out first with Sam—his hand on her lower back, Madison couldn’t help but notice—and Liam followed close behind.

But before Madison could follow, Levi pulled her aside.

“So the plan was to make us pay for going out with the boys, hmm?” Levi’s low, sexy voice sent shivers over her skin.

“My ~plan~ was to just let you dream about this dress, but I suppose having you forced to keep your hands off me will be just as fun,” she said.

She turned on her heel to leave, but this time it was Ethan who stopped her.

He grabbed her wrist, and in a second his lips were on hers in a quick but intense kiss.

He smirked.

“I’m sure there’ll be a private place somewhere.”

***

The Blue Cave was literally a club built in an immense cave above the ocean.

It was already packed when they arrived, but they managed to get a few bottles at the bar—and miraculously found an area to sit in a corner not far from the dance floor.

A few rounds later, Liam was dancing with a pretty brunette, and Ezra and Sam were dancing together, oblivious to everyone else.

Madison didn’t mind. The more her friend kept her overprotective brother distracted, the less she and the twins needed to pretend.

“It’s good to see Liam having some fun!” she said to the twins as Ethan poured three more shots.

“Yeah, he’s kind of been a moody asshole lately,” Levi said.

“Really?” She was surprised by that, but the twins did see him a lot more than she did. “That’s not like him. I thought he was just tired from the problems with the new gym, but now I’m wondering if something’s going on with him.”

Ethan and Levi exchanged a quick look.

“Wait, do you guys know something?”

“Just attorney-client stuff.” Ethan handed one shot to Madison and one to Levi. “Nothing for you to worry about.” He held up his shot glass. “To us!”

They clinked their glasses together and downed the shots.

“Let’s dance!” Levi shouted over the music. He took Madison’s hand and dragged her through the crowd, followed like a shadow by Ethan, who had his hand on her back.

They worked their way onto the dance floor by Ezra and Sam, and Madison squeezed herself between the boys.

“Nice of you to join us,” Ezra said sarcastically, letting his hand slide down Sam’s body—way too comfortably. Almost like it had been there before.

Madison narrowed her eyes. “Well, we didn’t want to interrupt you and ~Sam~,” she fired back.

Ezra just turned his attention back to her friend without responding.

Madison planned to question them both later, but for now she took advantage of her brothers’ distraction to rock her hips seductively against the twins.

“Madison,” Levi groaned quietly, “why are you doing that?”

She smirked and locked eyes with him. “I don’t know ~what~ you’re referring to, Levi Thompson.”

Licking her lips, Madison started to swing her hips to the rhythm of the music. She moved her hands over her body, following the flow of the dance.

She closed her eyes and let her head fall back to show off her neck, then ran a hand over her soft skin and let her finger rest on her exposed cleavage.

Without missing a beat, she tossed her head and moved her hands down the sides of her body, from her breasts to the hem of the dress. She pulled her dress up her thighs, exposing more skin.

“~Jesus~,” Ethan and Levi said in unison.

“Pure evil,” Ethan added, licking his lips. “I suggest you stop if you don’t want us to take you right here.”

“Hmm, I thought my first time would be more…private.” Madison was having fun trying to provoke them, and from the frustration in their eyes, she was doing a good job.

“It won’t be if you don’t stop,” Ethan growled.

Levi put his hand on her waist. “What do you say we get out of here?”

The twins looked at each other, identical smirks spreading across their faces, then turned back at her.

“You’re gonna need to be a good actress though,” Levi warned.

She glanced over to where Liam was dancing, and when he met her eyes over the brunette’s shoulder, it struck Madison that he’d been faking his good mood tonight.

“I think Liam’s been watching us.”

“Act drunk,” Ethan replied quickly, then walked over to Ezra.

The music was too loud for her to hear what they were saying, but she did as he said and slumped against Levi, hanging on to his shoulder.

Ethan pointed at her, and Ezra shook his head. Then Liam came up to them and jumped into the conversation, and finally Ethan returned to Madison and Levi.

“Let’s go, drunk-ass.” He pretended to hold her up, and the three of them staggered out of the club.

“What did you tell them?” she asked when they were outside in the parking lot.

“Just that you were drunk…and since they seemed busy and we have an early day tomorrow, we would take you home.

“Oh, and also, since they might be bringing guests home and you had the day off tomorrow, I suggested you spend the night at our place.”

Her mouth dropped open. She hadn’t stayed at their place in at least fifteen years.

“And Ezra said yes?”

“No, Liam did.”

Before she could say anything else, Ethan kissed her roughly, causing her to melt into pure lust.

“Let’s go,” she whispered.

***

Levi pulled into their driveway and stopped the car so fast that Ethan and Madison, who were sitting in the back, bumped heads.

“Jesus, Levi!” Madison laughed.

And almost before she knew what was happening, Levi had opened the door and thrown her over his shoulder to take her inside.

The house was as dark inside as it was outside, and the twins hurried through so fast that she had no idea where she was in the house.

It was only when Levi stopped and dropped her on a bed that she was able to orient herself.

“That was fast.”

Levi winked. “Couldn’t wait any longer.”

He crawled onto the bed and pinned her to the mattress, bending to put his lips on her neck. He started a trail of small wet kisses that had her moaning softly.

He pulled at her dress. “I want you to take this off.”

His tone was too hot and demanding to say no, so arching her back a little, she peeled off her dress and tossed it aside.

She moved her hand to her stomach and stroked it a little.

“Perfection,” Ethan crooned, and her eyes flew to him.

He had already stripped, and his glorious erection had Madison biting her lips and clenching her inner thighs.

Ethan joined her and Levi on the mattress and sat on his knees beside her.

“We won’t be going all the way tonight, but we ~will~ be trying something new,” Levi said. He pulled away to undress.

The promise in his tone made it hard for her to be ~too~ disappointed, but Ethan stroked her hair tenderly anyway. “We just want to make sure you’re ready for us when we do make love to you.”

“I know.” She moved her hand toward Ethan. “I guess I still have things to learn first.”

His only answer was a gasp as she wrapped her hand around his erection.

Levi got back on the bed and slid his fingers under the waistband of her panties. “I’d say that it’s time for these to go as well.”

He gave her a peck on the lips then waited, his hand unmoving.

She nodded.

“Good girl.”

And in one sharp movement, he yanked her panties down and tossed them aside.