: Part 1 – Chapter 4
The Hate U Give
That night, Natasha tries to convince me to follow her to the fire hydrant, and Khalil begs me to go for a ride with him.
I force a smile, my lips trembling, and tell them I canât hang out. They keep asking, and I keep saying no.
Darkness crawls toward them. I try to warn them, but my voice doesnât work. The shadow swallows them up in an instant. Now it creeps toward me. I back away, only to find it behind me. . . .
I wake up. My clock glows with the numbers: 11:05.
I suck in deep breaths. Sweat glues my tank top and basketball shorts to my skin. Sirens scream nearby, and Brickz and other dogs bark in response.
Sitting on the side of my bed, I rub my face, as if thatâll wipe the nightmare away. No way I can go back to sleep. Not if it means seeing them again.
My throat is lined with sandpaper and aches for water. When my feet touch the cold floor, goose bumps pop up all over me. Daddy always has the air conditioning on high in the spring and summer, turning the house into a meat locker. The rest of us shiver our butts off, but he enjoys it, saying, âA liâl cold never hurt nobody.â A lie.
I drag myself down the hall. Halfway to the kitchen I hear Momma say, âWhy canât they wait? She just saw one of her best friends die. She doesnât need to relive that right now.â
I stop. Light from the kitchen stretches into the hallway.
âWe have to investigate, Lisa,â says a second voice. Uncle Carlos, Mommaâs older brother. âWe want the truth as much as anyone.â
âYou mean yâall wanna justify what that pig did,â Daddy says. âInvestigate my ass.â
âMaverick, donât make this something itâs not,â Uncle Carlos says.
âA sixteen-year-old black boy is dead because a white cop killed him. What else could it be?â
âShhh!â Momma hisses. âKeep it down. Starr had the hardest time falling asleep.â
Uncle Carlos says something, but itâs too low for me to hear. I inch closer.
âThis isnât about black or white,â he says.
âBullshit,â says Daddy. âIf this was out in Riverton Hills and his name was Richie, we wouldnât be having this conversation.â
âI heard he was a drug dealer,â says Uncle Carlos.
âAnd that makes it okay?â Daddy asks.
âI didnât say it did, but it could explain Brianâs decision if he felt threatened.â
A ânoâ lodges in my throat, aching to be yelled out. Khalil wasnât a threat that night.
And what made the cop think he was a drug dealer?
Wait.
Thatâs One-Fifteenâs name?
âOh, so you know him,â Daddy mocks. âI ainât surprised.â
âHeâs a colleague, yes and a good guy, believe it or not. Iâm sure this is hard on him. Who knows what he was thinking at the time?â
âYou said it yourself, he thought Khalil was a drug dealer,â Daddy says. âA . Why he assumed that though? What? By looking at Khalil? Explain that, Detective.â
Silence.
âWhy was she even in the car with a drug dealer?â Uncle Carlos asks. âLisa, I keep telling you, you need to move her and Sekani out of this neighborhood. Itâs poisonous.â
âIâve been thinking about it.â
âAnd weâre not going anywhere,â Daddy says.
âMaverick, sheâs seen two of her friends get killed,â Momma says. âTwo! And sheâs only sixteen.â
âAnd one was at the hands of a person who was supposed to protect her! What, you think if you live next door to them, theyâll treat you different?â
âWhy does it always have to be about race with you?â Uncle Carlos asks. âOther races arenât killing us nearly as much as weâre killing ourselves.â
âNe-gro, please. If I kill Tyrone, Iâm going to prison. If a cop kills me, heâs getting put on leave. Maybe.â
âYou know what? Thereâs no point having this conversation with you,â Uncle Carlos says. âWill you at least consider letting Starr speak to the detectives handling the case?â
âWe should probably get her an attorney first, Carlos,â Momma says.
âThatâs not necessary right now,â he says.
âAnd it wasnât necessary for that cop to pull the trigger,â says Daddy. âYou really think we gonâ let them talk to our daughter and twist her words around because she doesnât have a lawyer?â
âNobodyâs going to twist her words around! I told you, we want the truth to come out too.â
âOh, we know the truth, thatâs not what we want,â says Daddy. â
want justice.â
Uncle Carlos sighs. âLisa, the sooner she talks to the detectives, the better. It will be a simple process. All she has to do is answer some questions. Thatâs it. No need to spend money to get an attorney just yet.â
âFrankly, Carlos, we donât want anyone to know Starr was there,â Momma says. âSheâs scared. I am too. Who knows whatâs gonna happen?â
âI get that, but I assure you sheâll be protected. If you donât trust the system, can you at least trust me?â
âI donât know,â says Daddy. âCan we?â
âYou know what, Maverick? Iâve just about had it with youââ
âYou can get out my house then.â
âIt wouldnât even be your house if it wasnât for me and my mom!â
âYâall stop!â Momma says.
I shift my weight, and goddamn if the floor doesnât creak, which is like sounding an alarm. Momma glances around the kitchen doorway and down the hall, straight at me. âStarr baby, what you doing up?â
Now I have no choice but to go to the kitchen. The three of them are sitting around the table, my parents in their pajamas and Uncle Carlos in some sweats and a hoodie.
âHey, baby girl,â he says. âWe didnât wake you up, did we?â
âNo,â I say, sitting next to Momma. âI was already awake. Nightmares.â
All of them look sympathetic even though I didnât say it for sympathy. I kinda hate sympathy.
âWhat are you doing here?â I ask Uncle Carlos.
âSekani has a stomach bug and begged me to bring him home.â
âAnd your uncle was just getting ready to leave,â Daddy adds.
Uncle Carlosâs jaw twitches. His face has gotten rounder since he made detective. He has Mommaâs âhigh yellaâ complexion, as Nana calls it, and when he gets mad, his face turns deep red, like it is now.
âIâm sorry about Khalil, baby girl,â he says. âI was just telling your parents how the detectives would like for you to come in and answer a few questions.â
âBut you donât have to do it if you donât wanna,â Daddy says.
âYou know whatââ Uncle Carlos begins.
âStop. Please?â says Momma. She looks at me. âMunch, do you wanna talk to the cops?â
I swallow. I wish I could say yes, but I donât know. On one hand, itâs the cops. Itâs not like Iâll be telling just anybody.
On the other hand, . One of them killed Khalil.
But Uncle Carlos is a cop, and he wouldnât ask me to do something that would hurt me.
âWill it help Khalil get justice?â I ask.
Uncle Carlos nods. âIt will.â
âWill One-Fifteen be there?â
âWho?â
âThe officer, thatâs his badge number,â I say. âI remember it.â
âOh. No, he wonât be there. I promise. Itâll be okay.â
Uncle Carlosâs promises are guarantees, sometimes even more than my parentsâ. He never uses that word unless he absolutely means it.
âOkay,â I say. âIâll do it.â
âThank you.â Uncle Carlos comes over and gives me two kisses to my forehead, the way heâs done since he used to tuck me in. âLisa, just bring her after school on Monday. It shouldnât take too long.â
Momma gets up and hugs him. âThank you.â She walks him down the hall, toward the front door. âBe safe, okay? And text me when you get home.â
âYes, maâam. Sounding like our momma,â he teases.
âWhatever. You just better text meââ
âOkay, okay. Good night.â
Momma comes back to the kitchen, pulling her robe together. âMunch, your father and I are visiting Ms. Rosalie in the morning instead of going to church. Youâre welcome to come if you want.â
âYeah,â Daddy says. âAnd ainât no uncle pressuring you to go.â
Momma cuts him a quick glare, then turns to me. âSo, you think youâre up for it, Starr?â
Talking to Ms. Rosalie may be harder than talking to the cops, honestly. But I owe it to Khalil to pay his grandmother a visit. She may not even know I was a witness to the shooting. If she somehow does and wants to know what happened, more than anybody she has the right to ask.
âYeah. Iâll go.â
âWe better find her an attorney before she talks to the detectives,â Daddy says.
âMaverick.â Momma sighs. âIf Carlos doesnât think itâs necessary just yet, I trust his judgment. Plus Iâll be with her the entire time.â
âGood thing somebody trusts his judgment,â says Daddy. âAnd you really been thinking again âbout moving? We discussed this already.â
âMaverick, Iâm not going there with you tonight.â
âHow we gonâ change anything around here if weââ
âMav-rick!â she says through gritted teeth. Whenever Momma breaks a name down like that, you better hope itâs not yours. âI said Iâm not going there tonight.â She side-eyes him, waiting for the comeback. There isnât one. âTry and get some sleep, baby,â she tells me, and kisses my cheek before going to their room.
Daddy goes to the refrigerator. âYou want some grapes?â
âYeah. How come you and Uncle Carlos always fighting?â
ââCause he a buster.â He joins me at the table with a bowl of white grapes. âBut for real, he ainât never liked me. Thought I was a bad influence on your momma. Lisa was wild when I met her though, like all them other Catholic school girls.â
âI bet he was more protective of Momma than Seven is with me, huh?â
âOh, yeah,â he says. âCarlos acted like he was Lisaâs daddy. When I got locked up, he moved yâall in with him and blocked my calls. Even took her to a divorce attorney.â He grins. âStill couldnât get rid of me.â
I was three when Daddy went in prison, six when he got out. A lot of my memories include him, but a lot of my firsts donât. First day of school, the first time I lost a tooth, the first time I rode a bike without training wheels. In those memories, Uncle Carlosâs face is where Daddyâs shouldâve been. I think thatâs the real reason theyâre always fighting.
Daddy drums the mahogany surface of the dining table, making a beat. âThe nightmares will go away after a while,â he says. âTheyâre always the worst right after.â
Thatâs how it was with Natasha. âHow many people have you seen die?â
âEnough. Worst one was my cousin Andre.â His finger seems to instinctively trace the tattoo on his forearmâan with a crown over it. âA drug deal turned into a robbery, and he got shot in the head twice. Right in front of me. A few months before you were born, in fact. Thatâs why I named you Starr.â He gives me a small smile. âMy light during all that darkness.â
Daddy chomps on some grapes. âDonât be scared âbout Monday. Tell the cops the truth, and donât let them put words in your mouth. God gave you a brain. You donât need theirs. And remember that you didnât do nothing wrongâthe cop did.
Donât let them make you think otherwise.â
Somethingâs bugging me. I wanted to ask Uncle Carlos, but I couldnât for some reason. Daddyâs different though. While Uncle Carlos somehow keeps impossible promises, Daddy keeps it real with me. âYou think the cops want Khalil to have justice?â I ask.
The truth casts a shadow over the kitchenâpeople like us in situations like this become hashtags, but they rarely get justice. I think we all wait for that one time though, when it ends right.
Maybe this can be it.
âI donât know,â Daddy says. âI guess weâll find out.â
Sunday morning, we pull up to a small yellow house. Bright flowers bloom below the front porch. I used to sit with Khalil on that porch.
My parents and I hop out the truck. Daddy carries a foil-covered pan of lasagna that Momma made. Sekani claims heâs still not feeling good, so he stayed home. Sevenâs there with him. I donât buy this âsickâ act thoughâSekani always gets some kinda bug right as spring break ends.
Going up Ms. Rosalieâs walkway floods me with memories. I have scars tattooed on my arms and legs from falls on this concrete. One time I was on my scooter, and Khalil pushed me off âcause I hadnât given him a turn. When I got up, skin was missing from most of my knee. I never screamed so loud in my life.
We played hopscotch and jumped rope on this walkway too. Khalil never wanted to play at first, talking about how those were girlsâ games. He always gave in when me and Natasha said the winner got a Freeze Cupâfrozen Kool-Aid in a Styrofoam cupâor a pack of âNileators,â a.k.a. Now and Laters. Ms. Rosalie was the neighborhood Candy Lady.
I was at her house almost as much as I was at my own. Momma and Ms. Rosalieâs youngest daughter, Tammy, were best friends growing up. When Momma got pregnant with me, she was in her senior year of high school and Nana put her out the house. Ms. Rosalie took her in until my parents eventually got an apartment of their own. Momma says Ms. Rosalie was one of her biggest supporters and cried at her high school graduation like it was her own daughter walking across the stage.
Three years later, Ms. Rosalie saw Momma and me at Wyattâsâthis was way before it became our store. She asked my mom how college was going. Momma told her that with Daddy in prison, she couldnât afford daycare and that Nana wouldnât take care of me âcause I wasnât her baby and therefore I wasnât her problem. So Momma was thinking about dropping out. Ms. Rosalie told her to bring me to her house the next day and that she better not say a word about paying her. She babysat me and later Sekani the whole time Momma was in school.
Momma knocks on the door, rattling the screen. Ms.
Tammy answers in a head wrap, T-shirt, and sweatpants. She unhooks the locks, hollering back, âMaverick, Lisa, and Starr are here, Ma.â
The living room looks just like it did when Khalil and I played hide-and-seek in it. Thereâs still plastic on the sofa and recliner. If you sit on them too long in the summer while wearing shorts, the plastic nearly glues to your legs.
âHey, Tammy girl,â Momma says, and they hug long and hard. âHow you doing?â
âIâm hanging in there.â Ms. Tammy hugs Daddy, then me. âJust hate that this is the reason I had to come home.â
Itâs so weird looking at Ms. Tammy. She looks the way Khalilâs momma, Ms. Brenda, would look if Ms. Brenda wasnât on crack. A lot like Khalil. Same hazel eyes and dimples. One time Khalil said he wished Ms. Tammy was his momma instead so he could live in New York with her. I used to joke and tell him she didnât have time for him. I wish I never said that.
âWhere you want me to put this lasagna, Tam?â Daddy asks her.
âIn the refrigerator, if you can find room,â she says, as he heads toward the kitchen. âMomma said folks brought food all day yesterday. They were still bringing it when I got here last night. Seems like the whole neighborhood has stopped by.â
âThatâs the Garden for you,â Momma says. âIf folks canât do anything else, theyâll cook.â
âYou ainât ever lied.â Ms. Tammy motions to the sofa.
âYâall, have a seat.â
Momma and I sit down, and Daddy comes back and joins us. Ms. Tammy takes the recliner that Ms. Rosalie usually sits in. She gives me a sad smile. âStarr, you know, you sure have grown since the last time I saw you. You and Khalil both grew up soââ
Her voice cracks. Momma reaches over and pats her knee. Ms. Tammy a takes a deep breath and smiles at me again. âItâs good to see you, baby.â
âWe know Ms. Rosalie gonâ tell us she fine, Tam,â Daddy says, âbut how she really doing?â
âWeâre taking one day at a time. The chemoâs working, thankfully. I hope I can convince her to move in with me. That way I can make sure sheâs getting her prescriptions.â She sighs through her nose. âI had no idea Momma was struggling like she was. I didnât even know sheâd lost her job. You know how she is. Never wanna ask for help.â
âWhat about Ms. Brenda?â I ask. I have to. Khalil wouldâve.
âI donât know, Starr. Bren . . . thatâs complicated. We havenât seen her since we got the news. Donât know where she is. If we do find her though . . . I donât know what weâll do.â
âI can help you find a rehab facility near you,â Momma says. âSheâs gotta wanna get clean though.â
Ms. Tammy nods. âAnd thatâs the problem. But I think . . . I think this will either push her to finally get help or push her over the edge. I hope itâs the former.â
Cameron holds his grandmaâs hand as he leads her into the living room like sheâs the queen of the world in a housecoat. She looks thinner, but strong for somebody going through chemo and all of this. A scarf wrapped around her head adds to her majestyâan African queen, and weâre blessed to be in her presence.
The rest of us stand.
Momma hugs Cameron and kisses one of his chubby cheeks. Khalil called him Chipmunk because of them, but heâd check anybody stupid enough to call his little brother fat.
Daddy gives Cameron a palm-slap that ends in a hug. âWhatâs up, man? You okay?â
âYes, sir.â
A big, wide smile spreads across Ms. Rosalieâs face. She holds her arms out, and I walk into the most heartfelt hug Iâve ever gotten from somebody whoâs not related to me. Thereâs not any sympathy in it either. Just love and strength. I guess she knows I need some of both.
âMy baby,â she says. She pulls back and looks at me, tears brimming in her eyes. âWent and grew up on me.â
She hugs my parents too. Ms. Tammy lets her have the recliner. Ms. Rosalie pats the end of the sofa closest to her, so I sit there. She holds my hand and rubs her thumb along the top of it.
âMmm,â she says. âMmm!â
Itâs like my hand is telling her a story, and sheâs responding. She listens to it for a while, then says, âIâm so glad you came over. Iâve been wanting to talk to you.â
âYes, maâam.â I say what Iâm supposed to.
âYou were the very best friend that boy ever had.â
This time I canât say what Iâm supposed to. âMs. Rosalie, we werenât as closeââ
âI donât care, baby,â she says. âKhalil never had another friend like you. I know that for a fact.â
I swallow. âYes, maâam.â
âThe police told me you were the one with him when it happened.â
So she knows. âYes, maâam.â
Iâm standing on a track, watching the train barrel toward me, and I tense up and wait for the impact, the moment she asks what happened.
But the train shifts to another track. âMaverick, he wanted to talk to you. He wanted your help.â
Daddy straightens up. âFor real?â
âUh-huh. He was selling that stuff.â
Something leaves me. I mean, I kinda figured it, but to know itâs the truth . . .
This hurts.
But I swear I wanna cuss Khalil out. How he could sell the very stuff that took his momma from him? Did he realize that he was taking somebody elseâs momma from them?
Did he realize that if he does become a hashtag, some people will only see him as a drug dealer?
He was so much more than that.
âBut he wanted to stop,â Ms. Rosalie says. âHe told me, âGrandma, I canât stay in this. Mr. Maverick said it only leads to two things, the grave or prison, and I ainât trying to see either.â He respected you, Maverick. A lot. You were the father he never had.â
I canât explain it, but something leaves Daddy too. His eyes dim, and he nods. Momma rubs his back.
âI tried to talk some sense into him,â Ms. Rosalie says, âbut this neighborhood makes young men deaf to their elders. The money part didnât help. He was going around here, paying bills, buying sneakers and mess. But I know he remembered the things you told him over the years, Maverick, and that gave me a lotta faith.
âI keep thinking if only he had another day orââ Ms. Rosalie covers her trembling lips. Ms. Tammy starts for her, but she says, âIâm okay, Tam.â She looks at me. âIâm happy he wasnât alone, but Iâm even happier you were with him. Thatâs all I need to know. Donât need details, nothing else. Knowing you were with him is good enough.â
Like Daddy, all I can do is nod.
But as I hold Khalilâs grandmaâs hand, I see the anguish in her eyes. His little brother canât smile anymore. So what if people end up thinking he was a thug and never care? We care.
Khalil matters to us, not the stuff he did. Forget everybody else.
Momma leans across me and sets an envelope in Ms. Rosalieâs lap. âWe want you to have that.â
Ms. Rosalie opens it, and I catch a glimpse of a whole lot of money inside. âWhat in the world? Yâall know I canât take this.â
âYes, you can,â Daddy says. âWe ainât forgot how you kept Starr and Sekani for us. We werenât âbout to let you be empty-handed.â
âAnd we know yâall are trying to pay for the funeral,â Momma says. âHopefully thatâll help. Plus, weâre raising money around the neighborhood too. So donât you worry about a thing.â
Ms. Rosalie wipes a new set of tears from her eyes. âIâm gonna pay yâall back every penny.â
âDid we say you had to pay us back?â Daddy asks. âYou focus on getting better, aâight? And if you give us any money, we giving it right back, Godâs my witness.â
There are a lot more tears and hugs. Ms. Rosalie gives me a Freeze Cup for the road, red syrup glistening on the top. She always makes them extra sweet.
As we leave, I remember how Khalil used to run up to the car when I was about to go, the sun shining on the grease lines that separated his cornrows. The glimmer in his eyes would be just as bright. Heâd knock on the window, Iâd let it down, and heâd say with a snaggletooth grin, âSee you later, alligator.â
Back then Iâd giggle behind my own snaggleteeth. Now I tear up. Good-byes hurt the most when the other personâs already gone. I imagine him standing at my window, and I smile for his sake. âAfter a while, crocodile.â