: Part 1 – Chapter 15
The Hate U Give
It takes an untouched stack of pancakes for Momma to say, âAll right, Munch. Whatâs up?â
We have a table to ourselves in IHOP. Itâs early morning, and the restaurantâs almost empty except for us and these big-bellied, bearded truckers stuffing their faces in a booth. Thanks to them, country music plays on the jukebox.
I poke my fork at my pancakes. âNot real hungry.â
Somewhat a lie, somewhat the truth. Iâm having a serious emotional hangover. Thereâs that interview. Uncle Carlos. Hailey. Khalil. DeVante. My parents.
Momma, Sekani, and I spent the night at Uncle Carlosâs house, and I know it was more because Mommaâs mad at Daddy than it was about the riots. In fact, the news said last night was the first semipeaceful night in the Garden. Just protests, no riots. Cops were still throwing tear gas though.
Anyway, if I bring up my parentsâ fight, Mommaâs gonna tell me, âStay outta grown folksâ business.â Youâd think since itâs partially my fault they fought, it my business, but nope.
âI donât know whoâs supposed to believe that not hungry,â Momma says. âYouâve always been greedy.â
I roll my eyes and yawn. She got me up too early and said we were going to IHOP, just the two of us like we used to do before Sekani came along and ruined everything. He has an extra uniform at Uncle Carlosâs and can go to school with Daniel. I only had some sweats and a Drake T-shirtânot DA office appropriate. I gotta go home and change.
âThanks for bringing me here,â I say. With my awful mood, I owe her that.
âAnytime, baby. We havenât hung out in a while. Somebody decided I wasnât cool anymore. I thought I was still cool, so whatever.â She sips from her steaming mug of coffee. âAre you scared to talk to the DA?â
âNot really.â Although I do notice the clock is only three and a half hours away from our nine-thirty meeting.
âIs it that BS of an interview? That bastard.â
Here we go again. âMommaââ
âGot his damn daddy going on TV, telling lies,â she says. âAnd whoâs supposed to believe a grown man was that scared of two ?â
People on the internet are saying the same thing. Black Twitterâs been going in on Officer Cruiseâs dad, claiming his name should be Tom Cruise with that performance he put on. Tumblr too. Iâm sure there are people who believe himâHailey didâbut Ms. Ofrah was right: it backfired. Folks who never met me or Khalil are calling BS.
So while the interview bothers me, it doesnât bother me much.
âItâs not really the interview,â I say. âItâs other stuff too.â
âLike?â
âKhalil,â I say. âDeVante told me some stuff about him, and I feel guilty.â
âStuff like what?â she says.
âWhy he sold drugs. He was trying to help Ms. Brenda pay a debt to King.â
Mommaâs eyes widen. âWhat?â
âYeah. And he wasnât a King Lord. Khalil turned King down, and Kingâs been lying to save face.â
Momma shakes her head. âWhy am I not surprised? King would do some mess like that.â
I stare at my pancakes. âI shouldâve known better. Shouldâve known better.â
âYou had no way of knowing, baby,â she says.
âThatâs the thing. If I wouldâve been there for him, Iââ
âCouldnât have stopped him. Khalil was almost as stubborn as you. I know you cared about him a lot, even as more than a friend, but you canât blame yourself for this.â
I look up at her. âWhat you mean âcared about him as more than a friendâ?â
âDonât play dumb, Starr. Yâall liked each other for a long time.â
âYou think he liked me too?â
âLord!â Momma rolls her eyes. âBetween the two of us, Iâm the old oneââ
âYou just called yourself old.â
â
one,â she corrects, and shoots me a quick stank-eye, âand I saw it. How in the world did you miss it?â
âI dunno. He always talked about other girls, not me. Itâs weird though. I thought I was over my crush, but sometimes I donât know.â
Momma traces the rim of her mug. âMunch,â she says, and itâs followed by a sigh. âBaby, look. Youâre grieving, okay? That can amplify your emotions and make you feel things you havenât felt in a long time. Even if you do have feelings for Khalil, thereâs nothing wrong with that.â
âEven though Iâm with Chris?â
âYes. Youâre sixteen. Youâre allowed to have feelings for more than one person.â
âSo youâre saying I can be a ho?â
âGirl!â She points at me. âDonât make me kick you under this table. Iâm saying donât beat yourself up about it. Grieve Khalil all you want. Miss him, allow yourself to miss what couldâve been, let your feelings get out of whack. But like I told you, donât stop living. All right?â
âAll right.â
âGood. So thatâs two things,â she says. âWhat else is up?â
What isnât up? My head is tight like my brain is overloaded. Iâm guessing emotional hangovers feel a lot like actual hangovers.
âHailey,â I say.
She slurps her coffee. Loudly. âWhat that liâl girl do now?â
Here she goes with this. âMomma, youâve never liked her.â
âNo, Iâve never liked how youâve followed her like you canât think for yourself. Difference.â
âI havenâtââ
âDonât lie! Remember that drum set you begged me to buy. Why did you want it, Starr?â
âHailey wanted to start a band, but I liked the idea too.â
âHold up, though. Didnât you tell me you wanted to play guitar in this âband,â but Hailey said you should play drums?â
âYeah, butââ
âThem liâl Jonas boys,â she says. âWhich one did you really like?â
âJoe.â
âBut who said you should be with the curly-headed one instead?â
âHailey, but Nick was still fine as all get-out, and this is middle school stuffââ
âUh-uh! Last year you begged me to let you color your hair purple. Why, Starr?â
âI wantedââ
âNo.
, Starr?â she says. âThe real why.â
Damn. Thereâs a pattern here. âBecause Hailey wanted me, her, and Maya to have matching hair.â
âE-xact-damn-ly. Baby, I love you, but you have a history of putting your wants aside and doing whatever that liâl girl wants. Excuse me if I donât like her.â
With all my receipts put out there like that, I say, âI can see why.â
âGood. Realizing is the first step. So what she do now?â
âWe had an argument yesterday,â I say. âReally though, things have been weird for a while. She stopped texting me and unfollowed my Tumblr.â
Momma reaches her fork onto my plate and breaks off a piece of pancake. âWhat is Tumblr anyway? Is it like Facebook?â
âNo, and youâre forbidden to get one. No parents allowed. You guys already took over Facebook.â
âYou havenât responded to my friend request yet.â
âI know.â
âI need Candy Crush lives.â
âThatâs why Iâll never respond.â
She gives me âthe look.â I donât care. There are some things I absolutely refuse to do.
âSo she unfollowed your Tumblr thingy,â Momma says, proving why she can never have one. âIs that all?â
âNo. She said and did some stupid stuff too.â I rub my eyes.
Like I said, itâs too early. âIâm starting to wonder why weâre friends.â
âWell, Munchââshe gets another freaking piece of my pancakesââyou have to decide if the relationship is worth salvaging. Make a list of the good stuff, then make a list of the bad stuff. If one outweighs the other, then you know what you gotta do. Trust me, that method hasnât failed me yet.â
âIs that what you did with Daddy after Iesha got pregnant?â I ask. ââCause Iâll be honest, I wouldâve kicked him to the curb. No offense.â
âItâs all right. A lot of people called me a fool for going back to your daddy. Shoot, they may still call me a fool behind my back. Your nana would have a stroke if she knew this, but sheâs the real reason I stayed with your daddy.â
âI thought Nana hated Daddy?â I think Nana still hates Daddy.
Sadness creeps into Mommaâs eyes, but she gives me a small smile. âWhen I was growing up, your grandmother would do and say hurtful things when she was drunk, and apologize the next morning. At an early age I learned that people make mistakes, and you have to decide if their mistakes are bigger than your love for them.â
She takes a deep breath. âSevenâs not a mistake, I love him to death, but Maverick made a mistake in his actions. However, all of his good and the love we share outweighs that one mistake.â
âEven with crazy Iesha in our lives?â I ask.
Momma chuckles. âEven with crazy, messy, annoying Iesha. Itâs a little different, yeah, but if the good outweighs the bad, keep Hailey in your life, baby.â
That might be the problem. A lot of the good stuff is from the past. The Jonas Brothers, , our shared grief. Our friendship is based on memories. What do we have now?
âWhat if the good doesnât outweigh the bad?â I ask.
âThen let her go,â Momma says. âAnd if you keep her in your life and she keeps doing the bad, let her go. Because I promise you, had your daddy pulled some mess like that again, Iâd be married to Idris Elba and saying, âMaverick who?ââ
I bust out laughing.
âNow eat,â she says, and hands me her fork. âBefore I have no choice but to eat these pancakes for you.â
Iâm so used to seeing smoke in Garden Heights, itâs weird when we go back and there isnât any. Itâs dreary because of a late-night storm, but we can ride with the windows down. Even though the riots stopped, we pass as many tanks as we pass lowriders.
But at home smoke greets us at the front door.
âMaverick!â Momma hollers, and we hurry toward the kitchen.
Daddy pours water on a skillet at the sink, and the skillet responds with a loud sizzle and a white cloud. Whatever he burned, he burned it bad.
âHallelujah!â Seven throws his hands up at the table. âSomebody who can actually cook.â
âShut up,â Daddy says.
Momma takes the skillet and examines the unidentifiable remains. âWhat was this? Eggs?â
âGlad to see you know how to come home,â he says. He walks right by me without a glance or a good morning. Heâs still pissed about Chris?
Momma gets a fork and stabs at the charred food stuck to the skillet. âYou want some breakfast, Seven baby?â
He watches her and goes, âUm, nah. By the way, the skillet didnât do anything, Ma.â
âYouâre right,â she says, but she keeps stabbing. âSeriously, I can fix you something. Eggs. Bacon.â She looks toward the hall and shouts, âThe kind! Pig! Swine! Allâa that!â
So much for the good outweighing the bad. Seven and I look at each other. We hate when they fight because we always get stuck in the middle of their wars. Our appetites are the greatest casualty. If Mommaâs mad and not cooking, we have to eat Daddyâs struggle meals, like spaghetti with ketchup and hot dogs in it.
âIâll grab something at school.â Seven kisses her cheek. âThanks though.â He gives me a fist bump on his way out, the Seven way of wishing me good luck.
Daddy returns wearing a backwards cap. He grabs his keys and a banana.
âWe have to be at the DAâs office at nine thirty,â Momma says. âAre you coming?â
âOh, Carlos canât do it? Since he the one yâall let in on secrets and stuff.â
âYou know what, Maverickââ
âIâll be there,â he says, and leaves.
Momma stabs the skillet some more.
The DA personally escorts us to a conference room. Her name is Karen Monroe, and sheâs a middle-aged white lady who claims she understands what Iâm going through.
Ms. Ofrah is already in the conference room along with some people who work at the DAâs office. Ms. Monroe gives a long speech about how much she wants justice for Khalil and apologizes that itâs taken this long for us to meet.
âTwelve days, to be exact,â Daddy points out. âToo long, if you ask me.â
Ms. Monroe looks a bit uncomfortable at that.
She explains the grand jury proceedings. Then she asks about that night. I pretty much tell her what I told the cops, except she doesnât ask any stupid questions about Khalil. But when I get to the part when I describe the number of shots, how they hit Khalil in his back, the look on his faceâ
My stomach bubbles, bile pools in my mouth, and I gag.
Momma jumps up and grabs a garbage bin. She puts it in front of me quick enough to catch the vomit that spews from my mouth.
And I cry and puke. Cry and puke. Itâs all I can do.
The DA gets me a soda and says, âThatâll be all today, sweetie. Thank you.â
Daddy helps me to Mommaâs car, and people in the halls gawk. I bet they know Iâm the witness from my teary, snotty face, and are probably giving me a new nameâPoor Thing. As in, âOh, that poor thing.â That makes it worse.
I get in the car away from their pity and rest my head against the window, feeling like shit.
Momma parks in front of the store, and Daddy pulls up behind us. He gets out his truck and comes to Mommaâs side of the car. She rolls her window down.
âIâm going to the school,â she tells him. âThey need to know whatâs going on. Can she stay with you?â
âYeah, thatâs fine. She can rest in the office.â
Another thing puking and crying gets youâpeople talk about you like youâre not there and make plans for you. Poor Thing apparently canât hear.
âYou sure?â Momma asks him. âOr do I need to take her to Carlos?â
Daddy sighs. âLisaââ
âMaverick, I donât give a flying monkeyâs ass what your problem is, just be there for your daughter. Please?â
Daddy moves to my side of the car and opens the door. âCome here, baby.â
I climb out, blubbering like a little kid who skinned her knee. Daddy pulls me into his chest, rubbing my back and kissing my hair. Momma drives off.
âIâm sorry, baby,â he says.
The crying, the puking donât mean anything anymore. My daddyâs got me.
We go in the store. Daddy turns on the lights but keeps the closed sign in the window. He goes to his office for a second, then comes back to me and holds my chin.
âOpen your mouth,â he says. I open it, and his face scrunches up. â
We gotta get you a whole bottle of mouthwash. âBout to raise the dead with that breath.â
I laugh with tears in my eyes. Like I said, Daddyâs talented that way.
He wipes my face with his hands, which are rough as sandpaper, but Iâm used to them. He frames my face. I smile. âThere go my baby,â he says. âYouâll be aâight.â
I feel normal enough to say, âNow Iâm your baby? You havenât been acting like it.â
âDonât start!â He goes down the medicine aisle. âSounding like your momma.â
âIâm just saying. Youâve been extra salty today.â
He returns with a bottle of Listerine. âHere. Before you kill my produce with your breath.â
âLike you killed those eggs this morning?â
âAy, those were blackened eggs. Yâall donât know âbout that.â
â
knows âbout that.â
A couple of rinses in the restroom transform my mouth from a swamp of puke residue to normal. Daddy waits on the wooden bench at the front of the store. Our older customers who canât walk much usually sit there as Daddy, Seven, or I get their groceries for them.
Daddy pats the spot next to him.
I sit. âYouâre gonna open back up soon?â
âIn a liâl bit. What you see in that white boy?â
Damn. I wasnât expecting him to go right into it. âBesides the fact heâs adorableââ I say, and Daddy makes a gagging sound, âheâs smart, funny, and he cares about me. A lot.â
âYou got a problem with black boys?â
âNo. Iâve had black boyfriends.â Three of them. One in fourth grade, although that doesnât really count, and two in middle school, which donât count either âcause nobody knows shit about a relationship in middle school. Or about anything really.
âWhat?â he says. âI ainât know âbout them.â
âBecause I knew youâd act crazy. Put a hit on them or something.â
âYou know, that ainât a bad idea.â
âDaddy!â I smack his arm as he cracks up.
âDid Carlos know âbout them?â he asks.
âNo. He wouldâve ran background checks on them or arrested them. Not cool.â
âSo why you tell him âbout the white boy?â
âI didnât tell him,â I say. âHe found out. Chris lives down the street from him, so it was harder to hide. And letâs be real here, Daddy. Iâve heard the stuff youâve said about interracial couples. I didnât want you talking about me and Chris like that.â
âChris,â he mocks. âWhat kinda plain-ass name is that?â
Heâs so petty. âSince you wanna ask me questions, do you have a problem with white people?â
âNot really.â
â
?â
âAy, Iâm being honest. My thing is, girls usually date boys who are like their daddies, and I ainât gonâ lie, when I saw that whiteâChris,â he corrects, and I smile. âI got worried. Thought I turned you against black men or didnât set a good example of a black man. I couldnât handle that.â
I rest my head on his shoulder. âNah, Daddy. You havenât set a good example of what a black man should be. Youâve set a good example of what a should be. Duh!â
âDuh,â he mocks, and kisses the top of my head. âMy baby.â
A gray BMW comes to a sudden stop in front of the store.
Daddy nudges me off the bench. âCâmon.â
He pulls me to his office and shoves me in. I catch a glimpse of King getting out the BMW before Daddy closes the door in my face.
Hands shaking, I crack open the door.
Daddy stands guard in the entrance of the store. His hand drifts to his waist. His piece.
Three other King Lords hop out the BMW, but Daddy calls out, âNah. If you wanna talk, we do this alone.â
King nods at his boys. They wait beside the car.
Daddy steps aside, and King lumbers in. Iâm ashamed to admit it, but I donât know if Daddy stands a chance against King. Daddy isnât skinny or short, but compared to King, whoâs pure muscle at six feet, he looks tiny. Itâs damn near blasphemous to think like that though.
âWhere he at?â King asks.
âWhere who at?â
âYou know who. Vante.â
âHow Iâm supposed to know?â Daddy says.
âHe was working here, wasnât he?â
âFor a day or two, yeah. I ainât seen him today.â
King paces and points his cigar at Daddy. Sweat glistens on the rolls of fat on the back of his head. âYou lying.â
âWhy I gotta lie, King?â
âAll the shit I did for you,â King says, âand this how you repay me? Where he at, Big Mav?â
âI donât know.â
âWhere he at?â King yells.
âI said I donât know! He asked me for a couple hundred dollars the other day. I told him he had to work for it. So he did. I had some mercy and paid it all up front like a dumbass. He was supposed to come in today and didnât. End of story.â
âWhy he need money from you when he stole five Gs from me?â
âHell if I know,â Daddy says.
âIf I find out you lyingââ
âYou ainât gotta worry âbout that. Got too many problems of my own.â
âOh, yeah. I know âbout your problems,â King says, a laugh bubbling from him. âI heard Starr-Starr the witness they been talking âbout on the news. Hope she know to keep her mouth shut when she supposed to.â
âWhat the hell is that supposed to mean?â
âThese cases always interesting,â King says. âThey dig for information. Shit, they try to find out more âbout the person who died than the person who shot them. Make it seem like a good thing they got killed. They already saying Khalil sold drugs. That could mean problems for anybody who may have been involved in his hustle. So people gotta be careful when they talking to the DA. Wouldnât want them to be in danger âcause they ran their mouth.â
âNah,â Daddy says. âThe folks who were involved in the hustle need to be careful âbout what they say or even think âbout doing.â
There are several agonizing seconds of Daddy and King staring each other down. Daddyâs hand is at his waist like itâs glued there.
King leaves, pushing the door hard enough to nearly break the hinges, the bell clanging wildly. He gets in his BMW. His minions follow, and he peels out, leaving the truth behind.
Heâs gonna mess me up if I rat on him.
Daddy sinks onto the old peopleâs bench. His shoulders slump, and he takes a deep breath.
We close early and pick up dinner from Reubenâs.
During the short drive home, I notice every car behind us, especially if itâs gray.
âI wonât let him do anything to you,â Daddy says.
I know. But still.
Mommaâs beating the hell out of some steaks when we get home. First the skillet and now red meat. Nothing in the kitchen is safe.
Daddy holds up the bags for her to see. âI got dinner, baby.â
It doesnât stop her from beating the steaks.
We all sit around the kitchen table, but itâs the quietest dinner in Carter family history. My parents arenât talking. Sevenâs not talking. Iâm definitely not talking. Or eating. Between the disaster at the DAâs office and King, my ribs and baked beans look disgusting. Sekani canât sit still, like heâs itching to give every detail of his day. I guess he can tell nobodyâs in the mood.
Brickz chomps and slobbers over some ribs in his corner.
Afterward, Momma collects our plates and silverware. âAll right, guys, finish your homework. And donât worry, Starr. Your teachers gave me yours.â
Why would I worry about that? âThanks.â
She starts to pick up Daddyâs plate, but he touches her arm. âNah. I got it.â
He takes all of the plates from her, dumps them in the sink, and turns the water on.
âMaverick, you donât have to do that.â
He squirts way too much dishwashing liquid in the sink. He always does. âItâs cool. What time you gotta be at the clinic in the morning?â
âIâll be off again tomorrow. I have a job interview.â
Daddy turns around. âAnother one?â
one?
âYeah. Markham Memorial again.â
âThatâs where Aunt Pam works,â I say.
âYeah. Her dad is on the board and recommended me. Itâs the Pediatrics Nursing Manager. This is my second interview for it actually. They want some of the higher-ups to interview me this time.â
âBaby, thatâs amazing,â Daddy says. âThat means youâre close to getting it, huh?â
âHopefully,â she says. âPam thinks itâs as good as mine.â
âWhy didnât you guys tell us?â Seven asks.
ââCause itâs none of yâall business,â Daddy says.
âAnd we didnât want to get your hopes up,â Momma adds. âItâs a competitive position.â
âHow much does it pay?â Sevenâs rude self asks.
âMore than what I make at the clinic. Six figures.â
âSix?â Seven and I say.
âMommaâs gonna be a millionaire!â Sekani shouts.
I swear he doesnât know anything. âSix figures is the hundred thousands, Sekani,â I say.
âOh. Itâs still a lot.â
âWhat time is your interview?â Daddy asks.
âEleven.â
âOkay, good.â He turns around and wipes a plate. âWe can look at some houses before you go to it.â
Mommaâs hand goes across her chest, and she steps back. âWhat?â
He looks at me, then at her. âIâm getting us outta Garden Heights, baby. You got my word.â
The idea is as crazy as a four-point shot. Living somewhere other than Garden Heights? Yeah, right. Iâd never believe it if it wasnât Daddy saying it. Daddy never says something unless he means it. Kingâs threat mustâve really got to him.
He scrubs the skillet that Momma stabbed this morning.
She takes it from him, sets it down, and grabs his hand. âDonât worry about that.â
âI told you itâs cool. I can get the dishes.â
âForget the dishes.â
And she pulls him to their bedroom and closes the door.
Suddenly, their TV blares real loud, and Jodeci sings over it from the stereo. If that woman ends up with a fetus in her uterus, I will be completely done.
.
âIll, man,â Seven says, knowing the deal too. âTheyâre too old for that.â
âToo old for what?â Sekani asks.
âNothing,â Seven and I say together.
âYou think Daddy meant that though?â I ask Seven. âWeâre moving?â
He twists one of his dreads at the root. I donât think he realizes heâs doing it. âSounds like yâall are. Especially if Ma gets this job.â
â
?â I say. âYouâre not staying in Garden Heights.â
âI mean, Iâll visit, but I canât leave my momma and my sisters, Starr. You know that.â
âYour momma put you out,â Sekani says âWhere else you gonna go, stupid?â
âWho you calling stupid?â Seven sticks his hand under his armpit, then rubs it in Sekaniâs face. The one time he did it to me I was nine. He got a busted lip, and I got a whooping.
âYouâre not gonna be at your mommaâs house anyway,â I say. âYouâre going away to college, hallelujah, thank Black Jesus.â
Seven raises his brows. âYou want an armpit hand too? And Iâm going to Central Community so I can stay at my mommaâs house and watch out for my sisters.â
That stings. A little. Iâm his sister too, not just them.
I repeat. âYou never call it home.â
âYeah, I do,â he says.
âNo, you donât.â
âYeah.â
âShut the hell up.â I end that argument.
âOoh!â Sekani holds his hand out. âGimme my dollar!â
âHell no,â I say. âThat shit doesnât work with me.â
âThree dollars!â
âOkay, fine. Iâll give you a three-dollar bill.â
âIâve never seen a three-dollar bill,â he says.
âExactly. And youâll never see my three dollars.â