: Part 1 – Chapter 12
The Hate U Give
Iâm luring Brickz inside when it passes out front.
I watch it crawl down the street for the longest time till I get the sense to alert somebody. âDaddy!â
He looks up from pulling weeds around his bell peppers. âAre they for real with that?â
The tank resembles the ones they show on the news when talking about war in the Middle East. Itâs the size of two Hummers. The blue-and-white lights on the front make the street almost as bright as it is in daytime. An officer is positioned on top, wearing a vest and a helmet. He points his rifle ahead.
A voice booms from the armored vehicle, âAll persons found violating the curfew will be subject to arrest.â
Daddy pulls more weeds. âSome bullshit.â
Brickz follows the piece of bologna I dangle in front of him all the way to his spot in the kitchen. He sits there all content, chomping on it and the rest of his food. Brickz wonât act crazy as long as Daddyâs home.
All of us are kinda like Brickz, really. Daddy being home means Momma wonât sit up all night, Sekani wonât flinch all the time, and Seven wonât have to be the man of the house. Iâll sleep better too.
Daddy comes in, dusting caked dirt off his hands. âThem roses dying. Brickz, you been pissing on my roses?â
Brickzâs head perks up. He locks his eyes with Daddyâs but eventually lowers his head.
âI betâ not catch you doing it,â Daddy says. âOr we gonâ have a problem.â
Brickz lowers his eyes too.
I grab a paper towel and a slice of pizza from the box on the counter. This is like my fourth slice tonight. Momma bought two huge pies from Salâs on the other side of the freeway. Italians own it, so the pizza is thin, herby (is that a word?), and good.
âYou finished your homework?â Daddy asks.
âYep.â A lie.
He washes his hands at the kitchen sink. âGot any tests this week?â
âTrig on Friday.â
âYou studied for it?â
âYep.â Another lie.
âGood.â He gets the grapes out the refrigerator. âYou still got that old laptop? The one you had before we bought you that expensive-ass fruit one?â
I laugh. âItâs an Apple MacBook, Daddy.â
âIt damn sure wasnât the price of an apple. Anyway, you got the old one?â
âYeah.â
âGood. Give it to Seven. Tell him to look over it and make sure itâs aâight. I want DeVante to have it.â
âWhy?â
âYou pay bills?â
âNo.â
âThen I ainât gotta answer that.â
Thatâs how he gets out of almost every argument with me. I should buy one of those cheap magazine subscriptions and say, âYeah, I pay a bill, and what?â It wonât matter though.
I head to my room after I finish my pizza. Daddyâs already gone to his and Mommaâs room. Their TVâs on, and theyâre both lying on their stomachs on the bed, one of her legs on his as she types on her laptop. Itâs oddly adorable. Sometimes I watch them to get an idea of what I want one day.
âYou still mad at me âbout DeVante?â Daddy asks her. She doesnât answer, keeping her eyes on her laptop. He scrunches up his nose and gets all in her face. âYou still mad at me? Huh? You still mad at me?â
She laughs and playfully pushes at him. âMove, boy. No, Iâm not mad at you. Now give me a grape.â
He grins and feeds her a grape, and I just canât. The cuteness is too much. Yeah, theyâre my parents, but theyâre my OTP. Seriously.
Daddy watches whatever sheâs doing on the computer, feeding her a grape every time he eats one. Sheâs probably uploading the latest family snapshots on Facebook for our out-of-town relatives. With everything thatâs going on, what can she say? âSekani saw cops harass his daddy, but heâs doing so well in school. #ProudMom.â Or, âStarr saw her best friend die, keep her in your prayers, but my baby made the honor roll again. #Blessed.â Or even, âTanks are rolling by outside, but Sevenâs been accepted into six colleges so far. #HeIsGoingPlaces.â
I go to my room. Both my old and new laptops are on my desk, which is a mess. Thereâs a huge pair of Daddyâs Jordans next to my old laptop. The yellowed bottoms of the sneakers face the lamp, and a layer of Saran Wrap protects my concoction of detergent and toothpaste thatâll eventually clean them. Watching yellowed soles turn icy again is as satisfying as squeezing a blackhead and getting all the gunk out. Ah-maz-ing.
According to the lie I told Daddy, my homework is supposed to be done, but Iâve been on a âTumblr break,â a.k.a. I havenât started my homework and have spent the last two hours on Tumblr. I started a new blogâ
. It doesnât have my name on it, just pictures of Khalil. In the first one heâs thirteen with an Afro. Uncle Carlos took us to a ranch so we could âget a taste of country life,â and Khalilâs looking side-eyed at a horse thatâs beside him. I remember him saying, âIf this thing makes a wrong move, Iâm running!â
On Tumblr, I captioned the picture: âThe Khalil I know was afraid of animals.â I tagged it with his name. One person liked it and reblogged it. Then another and another.
That made me post more pictures, like one of us in a bathtub when we were four. You canât see our private parts because of all the suds, and Iâm looking away from the camera. Ms. Rosalieâs sitting on the side of the tub, beaming at us, and Khalilâs beaming right back at her. I wrote, âThe Khalil I know loved bubble baths almost as much as he loved his grandma.â
In just two hours, hundreds of people have liked and reblogged the pictures. I know itâs not the same as getting on the news like Kenya said, but I hope it helps. Itâs helping me at least.
Other people posted about Khalil, uploaded artwork of him, posted pictures of him that they show on the news. I think Iâve reblogged every single one.
Funny though: somebody posted a video clip of Tupac from back in the day. Okay, so every video clip of Tupac is from back in the day. Heâs got a little kid on his lap and is wearing a backwards snapback that would be fly now. He explains Thug Life like Khalil said he didâThe Hate U Give Little Infants Fucks Everybody. âPac spells out âFucksâ because that kid is looking dead in his face. When Khalil told me what it meant I kinda understood it. I really understand it now.
I grab my old laptop when my phone buzzes on my desk. Momma returned it earlierâhallelujah, thank you, Black Jesus. She said itâs only in case thereâs another situation at school. I got it back though, donât really care why. Iâm hoping itâs a text from Kenya. I sent her the link to my new Tumblr earlier. Thought sheâd like to see it since she kinda pushed me to do it.
But itâs Chris. He took note from Seven with his all-caps texts:
OMG!
THIS EPISODE WILLâS DAD DIDNâT TAKE HIM WITH HIM THE ASSHOLE CAME BACK AND LEFT HIM AGAIN NOW HEâS HAVING A BREAKDOWN WITH UNCLE PHIL MY EYES ARE SWEATING Understandable. Thatâs seriously the saddest episode ever. I text Chris back:
Sorry :(. And your eyes arenât sweating. Youâre crying, babe.
He replies:
LIES!
I say:
You ainât gotta lie, Craig. You ainât gotta lie.
He responds:
DID YOU REALLY USE A LINE FROM FRIDAY ON ME???
So watching nineties movies is kinda our thing too. I text back:
Yep ð
He replies:
BYE, FELICIA!
I take the laptop to Sevenâs room, phone in hand in case Chris has another breakdown. Some reggae chants meet me in the hall, followed by Kendrick Lamar rapping about being a hypocrite. Seven sits on the side of the lower bunk, an open computer tower at his feet. With his head down, his dreads hang loosely and make a curtain in front of his face. DeVante sits cross-legged on the floor. His Afro bobs to the song.
A zombie version of Steve Jobs watches them from a poster on the wall along with all these superheroes and characters. Thereâs a Slytherin comforter on the bottom bunk that I swear Iâll steal one day. Seven and I are reverse HP fansâwe liked the movies first, then the books. I got Khalil and Natasha hooked on them too. Momma found the first movie for a dollar at a thrift store back when we lived in the Cedar Grove projects. Seven and I said we were Slytherins since almost all Slytherins were rich. When youâre a kid in a one-bedroom in the projects, rich is the best thing anybody can be.
Seven removes a silver box from the computer and examines it. âItâs not even that old.â
âWhat are you doing?â I ask.
âBig D asked me to fix his computer. It needs some new DVD drives. He burnt his out making all them bootlegs.â
My brother is the unofficial Garden Heights tech guy. Old ladies, hustlers, and everybody in between pay him to fix their computers and phones. He makes good money like that too.
A black garbage bag leans against the foot of the bunk bed with some clothes sticking out the top of it. Somebody put it over the fence and left it in our front yard. Seven, Sekani, and I found it when we came home from the store. We thought it may have been DeVanteâs, but Seven looked inside and everything in it belonged to him. The stuff he had at his mommaâs house.
He called Iesha. She said she was putting him out. King told her to.
âSeven, Iâm sorryââ
âItâs okay, Starr.â
âBut she shouldnât haveââ
âI said itâs okay.â He glances up at me. âAll right? Donât sweat it.â
âAll right,â I say as my phone vibrates. I hand DeVante the laptop and look. Still no response from Kenya. Instead itâs a text from Maya.
Are u mad @ us?
âWhatâs this for?â DeVante asks, staring at the laptop.
âDaddy wants you to have it. But he said let Seven check it out first,â I tell him as I reply to Maya.
What do u think?
âWhat he want me to have it for?â DeVante asks.
âMaybe he wants to see if you actually know how to operate one,â I tell DeVante.
âI know how to use a computer,â DeVante says. He hits Seven, whoâs snickering.
My phone buzzes three times. Maya has responded.
Definitely mad.
Can the 3 of us talk?
Things have been awkward lately.
Typical Maya. If Hailey and I have any kind of disagreement, she tries to fix it. She has to know this wonât be a âKumbayaâ moment. I reply:
Okay. Will let u know when Iâm @ my uncleâs.
Gunshots fire at rapid speed in the distance. I flinch.
âGoddamn machine guns,â Daddy says. âFolks acting like this Iran or some shit.â
âNo cussing, Daddy!â Sekani says from the den.
âSorry, man. Iâll add a dollar to the jar.â
âTwo! You said the âg-dâ word.â
âAâight, two. Starr, come to the kitchen for a second.â
In the kitchen, Momma speaks in her âother voiceâ on the phone. âYes, maâam. We want the same thing.â She sees me. âAnd hereâs my lovely daughter now. Could you hold, please?â She covers the receiver. âItâs the DA. She would like to talk to you this week.â
Definitely not what I expected. âOh . . .â
âYeah,â Momma says. âLook, baby, if youâre not comfortable with itââ
âI am.â I glance at Daddy. He nods. âI can do it.â
âOh,â she says, looking from me to Daddy and back. âOkay. As long as youâre sure. I think we should meet with Ms. Ofrah first though. Possibly take her up on her offer to represent you.â
âDefinitely,â Daddy says. âI donât trust them folks at the DA office.â
âSo how about we see her tomorrow and meet with the DA later on this week?â Momma asks.
I grab another slice of pizza and take a bite. Itâs cold now, but cold pizza is the best pizza. âSo two days of no school?â
âOh, youâre going to school,â she says. âAnd did you eat any salad while youâre eating all that pizza?â
âIâve had veggies. These little bitty peppers.â
âThey donât count when theyâre that little.â
âYeah, they do. If babies can count as humans when theyâre little, veggies can count as veggies when theyâre little.â
âThat logic ainât working with me. So, weâll meet with Ms. Ofrah tomorrow and the DA on Wednesday. Sound like a plan?â
âYeah, except the school part.â
Momma uncovers the phone. âSorry for the delay. We can come in on Wednesday morning.â
âIn the meantime tell your boys the mayor and the police chief to get them fucking tanks out my neighborhood,â Daddy says loudly. Momma swats at him, but heâs going down the hall. âClaim folks need to act peaceful, but rolling through here like we in a goddamn war.â
âTwo dollars, Daddy,â Sekani says.
When Momma hangs up, I say, âIt wouldnât kill me to miss one day of school. I donât wanna be there if they try that protest mess again.â I wouldnât be surprised if Remy tried to get a whole week off because of Khalil. âI need two days, thatâs all.â Momma raises her brows. âOkay, one and a half. Please?â
She takes a deep breath and lets it out slowly. âWeâll see. But not a word of this to your brothers, you hear me?â
Basically, she said yes without saying yes outright. I can deal with that.
Pastor Eldridge once preached that âFaith isnât just believing but taking steps toward that belief.â So when my alarm goes off Tuesday morning, by faith I donât get up, believing that Momma wonât make me go to school.
And to quote Pastor Eldridge, hallelujah, God shows up and shows out. Momma doesnât make me get up. I stay in bed, listening as everybody else gets ready for the day. Sekani makes it his business to tell Momma Iâm not up yet.
âDonât worry about her,â she says. âWorry about yourself.â
The TV in the den blares some morning news show, and Momma hums around the house. When Khalil and One-Fifteen are mentioned, the volume lowers a whole lot and doesnât go back up until a political story comes on.
My phone buzzes under my pillow. I take it out and look. Kenya finally texted me back about my new Tumblr. She would make me wait hours for a response, and her comment is short as hell:
Itâs aight I roll my eyes. Thatâs about as close as Iâm gonna get to a compliment from her. I text back.
I love you too Her response?
I know âº
Sheâs so petty. Part of me wonders though if she didnât respond last night âcause of drama at her house. Daddy said Kingâs still beating Iesha up. Sometimes he hits Kenya and Lyric too. Kenyaâs not the type to talk about it like that, so I ask:
Everything okay?
, she writes back.
Short, but it says enough. There isnât much I can do, so I just remind her:
Iâm here if you need me Her response?
You better be See? Petty.
Hereâs the messed-up part about missing school: you wonder what you would be doing if you went. At eight, I figure Chris and I would just be getting to history since itâs our first class on Tuesdays. I send him a quick text.
Wonât be at school today.
Two minutes later, he replies.
Are you sick? Need me to kiss it and make it better? Wink wink He seriously typed âwink winkâ instead of two wink emojis. Iâll admit, I smile. I write back:
What if Iâm contagious?
He says:
Doesnât matter. Iâll kiss you anywhere. Wink wink.
I reply:
Is that another line?
He responds in less than a minute.
Itâs whatever you want it to be. Love you Fresh Princess.
Pause. That âLâ word completely catches me off guard, like a player from the other team stealing the ball right as youâre about to make a layup. It takes all of your momentum and you spend a week wondering how that steal slipped up on you.
Yeah. Chris saying âlove youâ is like that, except I canât waste a week wondering about it. By not answering, Iâm answering, if that makes sense. The shot clock is winding down, and I need to say something.
But what?
By not saying âIâ before âlove you,â heâs making it more casual. Seriously, âlove youâ and âI love youâ are different.
Same team, different players. âLove youâ isnât as forward or aggressive as âI love you.â âLove youâ can slip up on you, sure, but it doesnât make an in-your-face slam dunk. More like a nice jump shot.
Two minutes pass. I need to say something.
Love you too.
Itâs as foreign as a Spanish word I havenât learned yet, but funny enough it comes pretty easily.
I get a wink emoji in return.
Just Us for Justice occupies the old Taco Bell on Magnolia Avenue, between the car wash and the cash advance place. Daddy used to take me and Seven to that Taco Bell every Friday and get us ninety-nine-cent tacos, cinnamon twists, and a soda to share. This was right after he got out of prison, when he didnât have a lot of money. He usually watched us eat. Sometimes he asked the manager, one of Mommaâs girlfriends, to keep an eye on us, and he went to the cash advance place next door. When I got older and discovered that presents donât just âshow up,â I realized Daddy always went over there around our birthdays and Christmas.
Momma rings the doorbell at Just Us, and Ms. Ofrah lets us in.
âSorry about that,â she says, locking the door. âItâs just me here today.â
âOh,â Momma says. âWhere are your colleagues?â
âSome of them are at Garden Heights High doing a roundtable discussion. Others are leading a march on Carnation where Khalil was murdered.â
Itâs weird to hear somebody say âKhalil was murderedâ as easily as Ms. Ofrah does. She doesnât bite her tongue or hesitate.
Short-walled cubicles take up most of the restaurant. They have almost as many posters as Seven has, but the kind Daddy would love, like Malcolm X standing next to a window holding a rifle, Huey Newton in prison with his fist up for black power, and photographs of the Black Panthers at rallies and giving breakfast to kids.
Ms. Ofrah leads us to her cubicle next to the drive-through window. Itâs kinda funny too âcause she has a Taco Bell cup on her desk. âThank you so much for coming,â she says. âI was so happy when you called, Mrs. Carter.â
âPlease, call me Lisa. How long have you all been in this space?â
âAlmost two years now. And if youâre wondering, yes, we do get the occasional prankster who pulls up to the window and tells me they want a chalupa.â
We laugh. The doorbell rings up front.
âThatâs probably my husband,â Momma says. âHe was on his way.â
Ms. Ofrah leaves, and soon Daddyâs voice echoes through the office as he follows her back. He grabs a third chair from another cubicle and sets it halfway in Ms. Ofrahâs office and halfway in the hall. Thatâs how small her cubicle is.
âSorry Iâm late. Had to get DeVante situated with Mr. Lewis.â
âMr. Lewis?â I ask.
âYeah. Since Iâm here, I asked him to let DeVante help around the shop. Mr. Lewis needs somebody to look out for his dumb behind. Snitching on live TV.â
âYouâre talking about the gentleman who did the interview about the King Lords?â Ms. Ofrah asks.
âYeah, him,â says Daddy. âHe owns the barbershop next to my store.â
âOh, wow. That interview definitely has people talking. Last I checked it had almost a million views online.â
I knew it. Mr. Lewis has become a meme.
âIt takes a lot of guts to be as upfront as he is. I meant what I said at Khalilâs funeral, Starr. It was very brave of you to talk to the police.â
âI donât feel brave.â With Malcolm X watching me on her wall, I canât lie. âIâm not running my mouth on TV like Mr. Lewis.â
âAnd thatâs okay,â Ms. Ofrah says. âIt seemed Mr. Lewis impulsively spoke out in anger and frustration. In a case like Khalilâs, I would much rather that you spoke out in a more deliberate and planned way.â She looks at Momma. âYou said the DA called yesterday?â
âYes. Theyâd like to meet with Starr tomorrow.â
âMakes sense. The case was turned over to their office, and theyâre preparing to take it to a grand jury.â
âWhat does that mean?â I ask.
âA jury will decide if charges should be brought against Officer Cruise.â
âAnd Starr will have to testify to the grand jury,â Daddy says.
Ms. Ofrah nods. âItâs a bit different from a normal trial. There wonât be a judge or a defense attorney present, and the DA will ask Starr questions.â
âBut what if I canât answer them all?â
âWhat do you mean?â Ms. Ofrah says.
âIâthe gun in the car stuff. On the news they said there may have been a gun in the car, like that changes everything. I honestly donât know if there was.â
Ms. Ofrah opens a folder thatâs on her desk, takes a piece of paper out, and pushes it toward me. Itâs a photograph of Khalilâs black hairbrush, the one he used in the car.
âThatâs the so-called gun,â Ms. Ofrah explains. âOfficer Cruise claims he saw it in the car door, and he assumed Khalil was reaching for it. The handle was thick enough, black enough, for him to assume it was a gun.â
âAnd Khalil was black enough,â Daddy adds.
A hairbrush.
Khalil died over a fucking hairbrush.
Ms. Ofrah slips the photograph back in the folder. âItâll be interesting to see how his father addresses it in his interview tonight.â
Hold up. âInterview?â I ask.
Momma shifts a little in her chair. âUm . . . the officerâs father has a television interview thatâs airing tonight.â
I glance from her to Daddy. âAnd nobody told me?â
ââCause it ainât worth talking about, baby,â Daddy says.
I look at Ms. Ofrah. âSo his dad can give his sonâs side to the whole world, and I canât give mine and Khalilâs? Heâs gonna have everybody thinking One-Fifteenâs the victim.â
âNot necessarily,â Ms. Ofrah says. âSometimes these kinds of things backfire. And at the end of the day, the court of public opinion has no say in this. The grand jury does. If they see enough evidence, which they should, Officer Cruise will be charged and tried.â
âIf,â I repeat.
A wave of awkward silence rolls in. One-Fifteenâs father is his voice, but Iâm Khalilâs. The only way people will know his side of the story is if I speak out.
I look out the drive-through window at the car wash next door. Water cascades from a hose, making rainbows against the sunlight like it did six years ago, right before bullets took Natasha.
I turn to Ms. Ofrah. âWhen I was ten, I saw my other best friend get murdered in a drive-by.â
Funny how comes out easily now.
âOh.â Ms. Ofrah sinks back. âI didnâtâ Iâm so sorry, Starr.â
I stare at my fingers and fumble with them. Tears well in my eyes. âIâve tried to forget it, but I remember everything. The shots, the look on Natashaâs face. They never caught the person who did it. I guess it didnât matter enough. But it did matter.
mattered.â I look at Ms. Ofrah, but I can barely see her for all the tears. âAnd I want everyone to know that Khalil mattered too.â
Ms. Ofrah blinks. A lot. âAbsolutely. Iââ She clears her throat. âI would like to represent you, Starr. Pro bono, in fact.â
Momma nods, and sheâs teary-eyed too.
âIâll do whatever I can to make sure youâre heard, Starr. Because just like Khalil and Natasha mattered, you matter and your voice matters. I can start by trying to get you a television interview.â She looks at my parents. âIf youâre okay with that.â
âAs long as they donât reveal her identity, yeah,â Daddy says.
âThat shouldnât be a problem,â she says. âWe will absolutely make sure her privacy is protected.â
A quiet buzzing comes from Daddyâs way. He takes out his phone and answers. The person on the other end shouts something, but I canât make it out. âAy, calm down, Vante. Say that again?â The response makes Daddy stand up. âIâm coming. You call nine-one-one?â
âWhatâs wrong?â Momma says.
He motions for us to follow him. âStay with him, aâight? We on the way.â