Neighbors With Benefits: Chapter 60

We had a delightful Thanksgiving dinner despite what Tabitha had said. Everyone was warm and friendly as we filled our plates, and then our stomachs. And I was pretty sure Cat and Amy were playing footsie under the table.

After dinner, we watched football—The Lions game, not the Cowboys—in the living room while eating dessert. And then it was time for everyone to go home. Tabitha left first, giving me a tight hug at the door.

“Take care of Aiden for me,” she whispered.

“I promise I will.”

Amy hugged me when she left ten minutes later. “Don’t worry about my mom,” she whispered to me. “You’ll find the right time to tell her.”

I pulled back. “I’m sorry, what are we talking about?”

Amy winked at me. “I’m observant. I’ll leave it at that.”

Before she could leave, Cat came running up. “I’ll walk you out.”

I closed the door behind them, then went into the kitchen. Aiden was quietly putting food into storage containers, his face pinched in concentration.

“I’m sorry,” I said.

He flashed a quick smile without looking up. “Me, too.”

“How sad are you?”

“Um. Medium sad.” He met my eyes. “But I didn’t expect her to be supportive.”

“She will be supportive when we tell her,” I insisted. “Her opinion might change when she knows what the four of us have.”

“Maybe,” he said doubtfully.

“And if not,” Dante said while joining us, “it doesn’t fucking matter. The four of us will be happy.”

“I know,” Aiden said.

I rubbed his back. “I can think of another way the four of us can be happy tonight. Just as soon as Cat leaves.”

“I don’t think she’s coming back,” Bash called from the living room. “I saw the two of them get into an Uber together. They were making out.”

Dante grinned. “Fucking nice.”

“I don’t want to hear that!” Aiden groaned. “That’s my sister.”

“The good news is that means we can start cheering you up right now,” I said.

Aiden turned toward me and forced a smile. “I don’t know if I’m in the mood to be cheered up tonight.”

“Really?” I glanced at Dante, who was smiling already. He knew what I was thinking. We were always on the same wavelength. “Because I wanted to try something special tonight.”

That got Aiden’s attention. “Something special?”

“But if you’re not in the mood…” I started to walk away.

Aiden grabbed my arm. “I could be convinced.”

I gave him a quick kiss, then took him by the hand. “Dante, can you and Bash finish cleaning up in here?”

“As long as we can join you when we’re done with the dishes,” he replied.

In my sexiest voice, I said, “Oh, I’m counting on it.”

I led Aiden to his bedroom, both because I was going to give him some solo treatment first, and because he had the largest bed of the three guys. We were going to need all the room tonight.

I sat Aiden down on the edge of the bed and kissed him. He leaned back on his palms, allowing me to push in between his legs with my body. Without any other preamble, I unzipped his pants and then pulled them down.

“You don’t have to—” he began.

He cut off when I wrapped my fingers around his hard length and squeezed. “Stop talking.”

Aiden gave a start. “Oh. I’m getting take-charge Jazz tonight?”

Dropping to my knees, I replied, “That’s part of what you’re getting.”

I bent to my task, savoring the sound of Aiden sighing and relaxing on the bed. There were a lot of things I liked about having a relationship with my three neighbors, but always being nearby to comfort each other was a big one. Aiden had come to my rescue on several occasions after I’d had a bad day at work, like when I’d had to fire someone for stealing golf balls from the supply room. Now it was my turn to repay the favor.

I was good at my job, so to speak, especially now that we had been together long enough that I knew exactly what he liked. I could feel his thighs tensing underneath me, going relaxed again, then tensing once more as I pleasured him with my lips and tongue.

“I’m close,” he gritted out after a few minutes.

I replied by moaning around his tip.

“Slow down,” he said. “I want more than just this tonight.”

And you’ll get it, I thought, speeding up my work.

He made no more protests as I jacked him off into my mouth. Soon he was gasping and clutching the bed, fingers clinging to the comforter as he cried out and began to come. I groaned with satisfaction as his cock shuddered in my mouth, rope after rope of his warm seed hitting the back of my throat.

“This is just the appetizer,” I promised him, licking the last bit of come from his tip and smiling. “The main course is yet to come.”

He grabbed a handful of my hair and pulled me into a rough kiss. “I love it when you use kitchen talk.”

“What’s going on in here?” Bash asked as he sauntered into the bedroom.

“Seems obvious to me,” Dante replied, right behind him.

“It was a rhetorical question.”

Dante’s eyes were locked onto me, full of lust and anticipation. “Looks like we walked in at the end.”

“It’s just the beginning,” I promised, rising from my crouched position. “You two have to wait your turn, though.”

“Even though we spent the last ten minutes cleaning the kitchen?” Bash asked.

I pointed at the desk chair on the other side of the room. “You can wait there. And watch.”

I straddled Aiden and began kissing him more passionately than before. His response was hard and urgent, cupping my ass and squeezing tightly. I opened my mouth for his tongue and we French kissed in front of the other two, who had done as they were told and were watching from the desk. I parted my legs as Aiden’s hand slid along my thigh, welcoming his touch to my most sensitive place. His fingers rubbed my pussy through my jeans and I sighed against his churning lips. For a while, we put on a show for the other two, buying time for Aiden to recover for round two.

Soon Aiden’s lips weren’t the only ones I felt. Bash was behind me, touching and caressing. He removed my pants and bent down to kiss my shin, my knee, then my inner thigh. Finally he kissed my pussy lips, a few touches of love, before he began eating me out. His tongue slid in and out of my pussy with wonderful ecstasy, devouring me from behind. I turned to look across the room; Dante was leaning against the wall, his pants discarded and his long cock gripped in a fist while he watched with hungry eyes.

I winked at him, and he responded with a deep growl that I heard from across the room.

“What are you waiting for?” I crooned.

His lip curled in a sneer. “For you to beg for me to join.”

“Mmm, maybe I don’t want you to join,” I said. “The two of them are doing a good job by themselves.” It wasn’t a lie; Bash was eating me out from behind while Aiden kissed my neck, and my entire body was alive with desire. But I didn’t just want a threesome. Tonight, I wanted to do something new. Something all of us had been dreaming about.

“I’m good watching,” Dante said, calling my bluff.

I let out an annoyed groan. “Suit yourself.”

Dante chuckled, and continued watching.

For a little while, I surrendered to how my other two lovers felt. Aiden’s tongue swirled around my nipple and Bash was fingering me from behind, his tongue moving upward to rim my tight backdoor. A quick orgasm shook my body, like the preamble to a real earthquake.

“Mmm, he’s eating out my ass,” I moaned loudly.

Dante said nothing.

“Maybe I’ll let him fuck it,” I added. “Only him.”

I could feel Dante’s smile, but he still only watched.

Finally, I could stand it no longer. “Join us,” I said.

“No,” Dante replied simply. The word sounded like a curse in my ears.

“Why not?”

“You know why.”

His previous statement echoed in my mind: I want to hear you beg. I glanced sideways at him, and he was sneering.

Damnit.

“Please join us,” I said lustily.

He didn’t move.

“I want your lips on my body too,” I said.

Nothing.

“I need you,” I begged.

His response was one word: “More.”

“Please,” I said, actually begging by this point. “I don’t want two of you. I want three. I need all three of you to fuck me on the bed, each of your cocks inside me at the same time. It’s all I’ve been able to think about for the past month, and now you’re finally all home at the same time. Please, Dante. Please fuck me.”

“Well, I’m rock hard again,” Aiden said underneath me.

Bash gave my ass a loud smack. “She’s ready for you, Dante.”

The third member of our group waited a few more agonizing seconds, then prowled toward us like a jaguar. Every step felt like an eternity, denying me what I wanted.

“Move,” he commanded.

Bash got out of the way, and Dante took his place behind me. He grabbed my ass with both hands, then slammed his cock into me from behind.

I tried to tell him that was exactly what I wanted, what I needed, but my tongue couldn’t form the words. All that came out was a long moan from deep within my throat. But Dante and I were always on the same page, and he knew exactly how I needed to be fucked. He pushed me down onto Aiden’s prone body and fucked the life out of me from behind, hard and rough and urgent.

“God damn,” he said sliding out of me and smacking my ass. “I always forget how tight you are. I’m not ready to come. We’re not done with you yet.”

“You’re not?” I asked innocently.

“Bash,” Dante said.

My blond lover lifted me off the bed, spun me around, then placed me on the edge of the bed. He took his turn fucking me missionary style, while his hips moved passionately and his tongue swirled in my mouth. Aiden reclined on the bed and watched while gently stroking his newly-erect cock. Dante reached between us and rubbed at my clit, bringing me to a second shivering climax that made me clench my inner muscles around Bash tightly.

“It’s like she’s trying to squeeze the come out of me,” Bash groaned, slowing down.

Dante clapped him on the back. “Sounds like it’s Aiden’s turn.”

“Don’t have to tell me twice.” Aiden’s hands were on me then, turning me away from him and fucked me on our sides, thrusting from behind while kissing my back and neck. His arm wrapped underneath me, squeezing like a snake while he drove into me faster and faster.

Dante was there again, meeting me on the other side. He grabbed my chin and kissed me roughly, then shoved his hand roughly between my legs and rubbed at my clit again. I closed my eyes and moaned as he got me off yet again. I was still crying out with intense ecstasy when he knelt in front of my face, pushing his cock against my lips and muffling my blissful cries with his hard length.

“How many times can we make her come tonight?” Aiden wondered, planting a hand on the back of my head and pushing me further down on Dante’s cock.

“As many as it takes,” Bash replied happily.

Then Dante decided he could wait no longer. He pulled me away from Aiden, sliding me on top of him until I was riding him. His chiseled face was all shadows in the darkness as he gazed up at me hungrily, and I drove my hips down on his cock harder and harder, fucking him like he was my possession. He leaned up and took one of my breasts in his mouth, nibbling gently but with enough force to send lightning bolts of pleasure through my chest.

Then I felt hands sliding along my back, caressing my skin until they reached my round ass. Bash grabbed my cheeks with both hands and squeezed, bouncing me up and down on Dante’s cock.

“So… is tonight the night?” he asked.

I moaned at what I thought he was implying. “Mmm hmm.”

“Ready for it?”

“Depends what it is.”

“I think she’s ready,” Dante crooned underneath me. “She can take it.”

“She’s going to love it,” Aiden agreed.

It was something I had fantasized about for months. Something I had been wanting to try since the day I first tried anal sex with Dante. There were three of them, and I had three holes…

It was just simple math, really.

While I rode him, Dante grabbed my ass with both hands and spread me wide for his friend. Bash’s fingers were suddenly there, rubbing down toward my rear entrance. He spread lube around my asshole like he normally did, inserting one finger, then two. Not very far—just deep enough to make sure I was properly lubed up.

I tensed for what came next, with both anticipation and excitement.

Bash knelt on the bed behind me. I felt him pushing aside Dante’s legs on the edge, getting situated for what he was about to do. Slowly, he pressed the tip of his cock against the tight ring of my ass. It slid inside easily, as it had in all the times we had done this. But what we hadn’t done was try it while someone else was fucking my pussy…

The pressure was intense. I felt his cock sliding into my ass, pushing against Dante’s. It hit new nerve endings that had never been hit before. It was different… but it was good.

Really good.

“That feels amazing,” I breathed, grinding against Dante while Bash’s cock slid deeper into my ass. “Hold it there for a second. Let me get used to it.”

“Told you she’d love it,” Aiden said over on the other side of the bed, watching while stroking his cock.

Bash let out a long sigh when half his cock was buried into my ass. “We’ll go slow.”

“You should do the moving,” Dante told me. “That way you can show us how much you can handle.”

I was eager to do just that. While the two men remained stationary, I engaged my thighs and lifted up off of Dante. Both cocks slid out just a little bit. Then I pushed back again, simultaneously driving them into my pussy and ass. My entire body shivered.

“Oh my God, that’s good,” I said. “Why haven’t we tried this before?”

I didn’t wait for an answer. I kept moving on them, fucking their dual-cocks with my body. Every movement I went a little bit farther off them, and then pushed back against them harder. Inch by inch their cocks went deeper inside me until I was taking nearly every inch with every stroke.

The two of them made noises I had never heard before. Deep, animal-like sounds that were full of effort and pleasure. It made me move faster, and faster, until I was crashing my body against them.

“Fuck me,” I finally begged. “I can take it, just fuck me.”

I didn’t need to tell Bash twice. He was like a racehorse leaving the starting block, grabbing my hips and driving his cock deep into my ass. The way he took over was so intense, so pleasurable, that my eyes clenched shut and I was lost in the waves of ecstasy that washed over me.

Two cocks inside me, I thought while they ravaged me. One in my ass and one in my pussy. I’m being double-penetrated.

I couldn’t bear for Aiden to be a bystander; I needed him to complete the group activity. I called out to him, begging him to come fuck my mouth. I turned my head and took his cock between my lips, sucking his tip while stroking as rapidly as I could. Helping him catch up.

None of us were going to last long, I knew.

“I love the way your mouth feels,” he moaned, putting a hand on the back of my head. “Fuck, Jazz…”

The three of them pumped their hard cocks inside of me, filling my three holes in naughty synchronicity. Time stood still as I was rocked by one orgasm, then another. Sex was an intensely mental thing, and emotional too, and knowing that I was being gangbanged by my three wonderful neighbors filled me with as much pleasure as the physical act itself.

Bash came in my ass first, hands squeezing my hips so tight it almost hurt, his roars penetrating the air in the bedroom. Dante gasped next as his cock spasmed in my pussy, filling me with his come while Bash’s come filled my ass. I sucked on Aiden faster and faster, moaning into his cock until he finally blew his load, shooting it into my mouth only seconds after the other two.

The three of them coming inside me at the same time? It was like being in heaven.

But Aiden wasn’t done with me yet. I was still coming down from the ecstasy when he pulled me off of Dante. The cocks in my pussy and ass disappeared, and Aiden pushed me down on my belly.

“I want that ass,” he said as he crouched behind me, cock pushing against my backdoor. “I need to fuck your ass, Jazz.”

“Fuck it,” I begged. “Take me, I’m yours, my ass is yours…”

He was rougher than the others, but I was warmed up and ready for it. He shoved his cock in my ass and buried it as deep as he could.

“Oh fuck!” he groaned. “I’m coming! Jazz, I’m coming in your ass!”

I felt his cock twitch and spasm inside me as he orgasmed for a third time, pushing his cock as deep as it would go, until I felt his balls resting against my pussy lips. He cried out as he filled my ass, adding his seed to Bash’s in my forbidden entrance. Somehow he came even longer than the first two times, when he shot his two loads into my mouth.

He panted afterwards, resting against my back. Covering me with his body while his cock remained inside me.

“Dude,” Bash said. “Did you just come a second time?”

“That…” Aiden gasped. “That’s never happened before.”

“Third time,” I said with satisfaction. “Once before you two joined, once again while we were all together, and then he came in my ass.”

“Coming a third time, almost immediately?” Dante asked with a rumbling laugh. “Aiden’s like a teenage boy who just discovered internet porn.”

“Or a woman,” I said with satisfaction. “I had a few back-to-back orgasms there.”

“A few?” Bash said, stroking my back. “That was half a dozen. At least.”

Aiden kissed the back of my neck. “Holy shit, that was good. You’ve got an amazing ass. Even better than your mouth.”

“They’re yours,” I whispered back at him. It felt good having his weight on me. “They’re yours whenever you want it.”

“Careful with that offer,” he replied. “I’ll take you up on it.”

“You’d better,” I said, twisting to smile up at him. “I do live right next door!”