: Chapter 8
If You Could See the Sun
I move through the requests quickly after that.
As I do, my life changes shape, fits into the mold of a new, bizarre routine: I spend my mornings going through new Beijing Ghost messages and choosing the most feasible tasks, lunchtimes developing a plan of action with Henry and sometimes Chanel, and classes only half paying attention to the teacher as I wait anxiously to turn invisible.
And on the days when I do turn invisible, and make that same mad dash out the classroom door, I always make sure to come back with a stolen, forged note from the nurseâs office, explaining a fictional chronic health condition I have that unfortunately makes me puke my guts out from time to time. Itâs enough to get the teachers off my back about my sudden, spontaneous absencesâthat, and the fact that I havenât fallen behind on any schoolwork.
Because when all my Beijing Ghost tasks are finally done for the day, I trudge back to my dorm, exhausted, and study, cramming lecture notes and slides and graphs into my brain until five or six in the morning, just in time to watch the watery sunrise through the window. Only then do I allow myself to be human and nap for about an hour. Two hours, max.
By the time November rolls around, I canât remember the last time I woke up without bloodshot eyes and a terrible, pounding headache, like someone has taken to squeezing my skull for fun. The trick to working through the pain, Iâve discovered, is by forcing myself to conjure up worst-case scenarios, to picture a future where I donât make enough money and have to leave Airington. Itâs like the reverse of guided meditation:
Youâre walking into the classroom of your new local school. Youâre sweating visibly, a heavy bag of books you havenât read gripped to your chest. All the students and teachers stare at you. The bell rings, and you take your first pop quiz: twenty-five pages of tiny Chinese characters you can hardly understand, much less answer. You feel sick. The test results are posted for everyone to see the next day. You push through the crowd, heart pounding, and find your name at the very bottom of the listâ¦
Compared to that, staying up all night feels almost like a luxury.
But despite everything, Iâd be lying if I said some part of me didnât enjoy the constant stream of tasks, the new notifications lighting up my phone. No, maybe enjoy is the wrong word. Itâs not about happiness; itâs about power. Itâs the thrill of being needed, of knowing things other people donât.
In the space of two months, Iâve learned more about my classmates than I have in my five years hereâlike how Yiwen, daughter of a billionaire, has been stealing entire plates of cupcakes from the café before school every day; how Sujin, another billionaireâs daughter, runs her own karaoke bar and spends all her money funding global warming research; how Stephen from Year Ten and Julian from Year Eleven have actually been making out behind the koi ponds when everyone thinks theyâre busy taking photos for the yearbook; or how Andrew She and Peter Ohâs parents are running for the same global director position at Longfeng Oil, and in fear of their latest campaign ideas being stolen, have advised their children to stay far away from each other.
Secrets, Iâm realizing, are their own kind of currency.
But even better is earning real currency, the satisfaction of seeing the numbers in my new bank account rise:
70,000 RMB.
100,000 RMB.
120,000 RMB.
More money than Iâve ever seen in my life. But even then, I know I could still earn more. I have to earn more. I still need another 130,000 RMB if I want to stay at Airington until I graduate.
Ten more tasks, I tell myself, and Iâll be able to make that much. Twenty more tasks and Iâll be able to pay for not just Airington, but an entire year of college.
Itâs addicting. Intoxicating.
Who cares if Iâm so busy I can barely breathe?
âMaybe you really are a ghost,â Chanel jokes to me one morning, when she sees me in the exact same position at my desk as the night before: head bent over my Chinese textbook, shoulders almost hunched to my ears. âThe kind of invincible ghost that like, doesnât need to eat or sleep or pee or anything, just runs on willpower alone. Seriously though,â she adds, peering at the tiny annotations and Post-it notes covering my textbook page. âHow the hell are you keeping up with all your subjects?â
I donât reply to her at the time, but the answer comes almost two weeks later, like some sort of sick joke.
And the answer is:Â Iâm not.
When I hurry into history class on Friday, I freeze.
All the desks and chairs have been rearranged. Spaced out around the classroom in neat, single files, instead of the usual messy clusters that are meant to inspire âgroup work.â
Most of my classmates are already sitting down, zipped-up bags tucked away under their seats, faces set in solemn lines as they methodically place their pens out in front of them. Someone sighs. Someone else mimes slitting their throat.
Thereâs a palpable tension in the air.
âWhatâs going on?â I say aloud.
Mr. Murphy, whoâs handing out a thick stack of papers, pauses and gives me a small, odd smile, like he thinks Iâve just made a bad joke. âThe thing youâve been waiting for all week, of course.â
I blink at him. âThe thingâ¦?â
The smile slips from his face. He frowns. âSurely you havenât forgotten about todayâs test, Alice? I mentioned it in class a week ago.â
At the word test, panic seizes my chest with such intensity I almost stagger back a step. A stone forms in my throat.
âWhat? But I didnâtâIââ I swallow, hard. People are starting to stare at me now, Henry amongst them. My face heats. My fingers fumble for the planner in my bag, for proof that there is no test, there canât be, that this must be a mistake. I have a perfect, color coded system, developed over my five years of school here. Foolproof. Red for important things and events, blue for homework and assignments, green for extracurricular activities.
But when I flip open the pages to last weekâs entry, thereâs red everywhere. Almost all of it is Beijing Ghost stuff, but squeezed right in between the lines find out if Vanessa Liuâs been bitching about Chung-Cha behind her back (waste of time tbhâVanessa bitches about everyone) and find Daniel Saitoâs locker combination, written so small I have to squint to decipher my own handwriting, are the words: Chinese Rev history test: next Friday.
The stone sinks to my stomach.
No.
âAlice?â Mr. Murphy looks at me, making very little effort to hide his surprise. His disappointment. I want to cry. âThe test is starting soonâ¦â
âY-yes, of course,â I choke out, forcing myself down into the closest empty seat. I duck my head and search for my pencil case with shaking fingers, but not before I catch the expressions on my classmatesâ faces: variations of pity, amusement, smugness, and most pronounced of all, shock.
A few summers back, some director at LinkedIn was invited to our school to talk about the importance of âpersonal brandingâ in the twenty-first century, and Iâve devoted the past five years to developing and strengthening mine. Iâm Alice Sun, the type A, straight-A student, the sole scholarship recipient, the perfectly programmed Study Machine, the girl who will help you get full marks on your group project. I do everything that is expected of me and more. I never underperform in important unit tests, much less forget when theyâre taking placeâuntil today, that is.
My gut roils.
So much for personal branding.
Just when I think I couldnât possibly feel any worse, Mr. Murphy comes around to my desk, hands me a blank test paper and says, very quietly, âEven if you forgot about the test, Alice, youâre a smart girl. Iâm sure youâll still do well.â
Heâs wrong.
Because even though Iâm smart, Iâm not that smart. Not the kind of prodigy-level smart you would expect to find at Harvard, the kind that would allow me to skip all my classes and still rank first in every test, that would make everything come easily. I donât say this in a self-pitying way, either; Iâve long acknowledged and accepted my limitations, and done my best to compensate for them with sheer willpower and hard work.
But without hard work, I doubt I can scrape so much as a B+ on this test. Even if I could, Iâve never been able to perform well when Iâm panicked. And Iâm panicking hard right now. My heart feels like itâs about to explode in my chest, my fingers shaking so badly I almost drop my pen.
No. Focus, I urge myself. I look up at the ticking clock. Seven minutes have passed already, and my test paper is still blank.
Normally, by this point, Iâd have written enough to cover two entire pages.
I attempt to answer the first question (âTo what extent did the Warlord Era prove a turning point in the development of the revolution in China?â), but all thatâs running through my head is fuck fuck Iâm so fucked in a maddening, highly unhelpful loop.
When I check the time again, another minute has already passed. And all around me, people are writing, answering each question perfectly, scoring every mark, and Iâ
I canât do this.
Oh god, I canât do this.
I take a deep, shuddering breath that fails to fill my lungs. Another. It sounds like Iâm hyperventilating. Fuck. Am I hyperventilating?
âAlice?â Mr. Murphy crouches down beside me. Heâs whispering, but itâs pointless. Almost comical. With the whole room silent, everyone can hear him. âYou look a little ill. Do you need to go to the nurseâs office againâ¦?â
More eyes turn to me. Pin me down in place.
All while Iâm trying to remember how to breathe like a normal person.
I donât trust myself to speakâIâm not sure Iâm even allowed to, under test conditionsâso I just shake my head. Force myself to write a few sentences, slowly, shakily, over the printed lines.
Itâs complete bullshit, of course. I have no dates memorized, no key events that I can recall. Iâd turned invisible for half our class on the Warlord Era, and mustâve missed the important points.
After a few seconds of excruciating silence, in which Mr. Murphy seems to confirm that Iâm not going to faint or throw up at his feet, he stands up and returns to the front of the room.
Meanwhile, the clock ticks on like a bomb.
âPlease put your pens down.â
I glance up from my test paper, where my writing crawls over the page like spiders, nearly illegible in my frenzy. Evie Wu and I are the only people left in the class; the test was short enough that everyone else turned it in early. Henry left the classroom before half an hour had even passed, his stride confident, his face calm.
Evieâs face, on the other hand, must look a lot like mine: bright red and shiny with sweat, as if sheâs just finished running a marathon. When she hands her test to Mr. Murphy, I notice that the entire back page is empty, save for one or two hastily scribbled words.
âThank you very much, Evie,â Mr. Murphy says. Then pauses. âI hope you didnât find this test too difficult. Iâd hate to have to give your mother another callâ¦â
Again, heâs whispering, and again, it serves absolutely no purpose when Iâm sitting less than five feet away, close enough to catch every word.
Evieâs eyes dart to me, clearly mortified, and I feel a swell of sympathy. Evie is the only student at Airington whoâs had to repeat a year, but itâs not her fault. Even though she has a Canadian passport, she was never actually taught any English growing up. Once, I caught a glance of Evieâs history textbook, and saw Chinese translations and annotations written in the margins for almost every word, little question marks drawn over certain phrases, entire blocks of text highlighted to mark out parts she didnât understand. I could almost feel the frustration pulsing out of those carefully marked lines.
The worst part is that Evieâs a genius, and not just in math and physics, but languages too. Sheâs in the most advanced Chinese class, and Wei Laoshi always gushes over her poems and essays and suggests not-so-delicately how heâd be happy if we could write with a tiny fraction of her skill, even goes so far as to compare her to Lu Xunâone of the most famous writers in modern China.
So, really, itâs only the English thatâs the issue.
Maybe thatâs why Mr. Murphy is whispering so loudly now. Why heâs speaking at half his usual speed, enunciating every syllable. He used to speak to me like that, too, when I first came to Airington, despite my insistence that English was my first language. Only after I aced five tests in a row did he seem to believe me.
Evie mumbles something back that I canât quite hear, rises from her chair and quickly gathers up her things.
Once sheâs left, Mr. Murphy turns to me.
âCan I have your test, Alice?â
I realize Iâve been gripping the paper to my chest like a lifeline, my knuckles almost white. I drop it. The pages flutter out like wings.
âY-yes. Of course,â I say, pushing it across the desk. I know the wise thing to do would be to just leave it at that, scrape up the little dignity and self-esteem I have and walk away, but instead I blurt out: âIâm sorry. Iâm so, so sorryâitâs really bad, I know it is, but I swear I donât usuallyâIâd neverââ
âDonât stress about it,â Mr. Murphy interrupts, with a little chuckle. âBesides, Iâve taught you for almost five years now, Alice. Your definition of âbadâ is rather different from that of your peers.â
But rather than reassure me, the kindness in his voiceâso sincere, and so unearnedâonly makes something inside me fissure. To my absolute horror, a pressure begins to build in my chest, climb up to my throat. My eyes blur.
Mr. Murphy looks alarmed. âHeyââ
Itâs as if someoneâs turned on a switch.
When I start crying, I canât seem to stop. Short, violent breaths rock my entire body, a disgusting amount of tears and snot flowing down my face even as I try, desperate, to wipe them away. I cry so hard my chest physically hurts. My head feels light. I sound unhinged, like an inconsolable child, a tortured animal.
I sound like Iâm about to die.
âHey,â Mr. Murphy says again, lifting a hand as if to pat my shoulder, then thinks better of it. Fear creases his bushy brows, and I wonder, dimly, if heâs scared Iâll sue him for psychological damage or something. Two years ago, a student in Year Thirteen did just that when he failed a major chemistry test. His parents were both lawyers; the student won in the end. âItâs okay.â
I manage to suppress my sobs long enough to stammer out: âS-s-sorry, I wasnâtââI hiccupââI wasnât even planning to cryâ¦or IâdââI hiccup againââIâd have l-let you know in advanceâ¦â
Mr. Murphyâs lips twitch slightly at that, like he thinks Iâm trying to be funny. Iâm not. Iâve just never cried at school before, not even when I broke my arm during an intense dodgeball game in PE, or that time when Leonardo Cruz called the prom dress Mama made for me cheap-looking in front of everyone. I never wanted any of my classmates or teachers to see me like thatâdistressed. Discomposed. Weak.
But I guess today is a day of firsts for everything.
âYou know, in all my years of teaching,â Mr. Murphy says, when my sobs have quietened a little, âI canât remember the last time anyone reacted soâ¦violently to a bad test experience.â Heâs not smiling anymore. âIs there something going on, Alice? Issues at home? Relationship drama? Friendship troubles?â His expression grows more uncomfortable with every question. âBecause you know, there areâ¦resources at Airington for that.â
When I look at him, confused, he clarifies, âWe have excellent school counselors whoâd be more than happy toââ
âNââ The unspoken word lodges in my throat. I shake my head instead, violently, to get my point across. I donât need someone to recommend meditation apps and listen to all my problems. I need to get my shit together. Pull my grades back up. Make more money.
I need to get out of here.
âIâI think Iâm fine now,â I say on a shaky breath. âAnd I have to get to class. So Iâllââ My voice threatens to crack again, and I gesture to the door.
Mr. Murphy purses his lips. Studies me for a beat.
âAll right,â he says finally, with an awkward smile. âWellâ¦just. Just take it easy, okay?â
âOkay,â I lie, already turning around to go.
Mr. Murphy means well, I know, but his words play over in my head like a taunt. What he doesnât understandâwhat most people here donât understandâis that I donât have the luxury of taking it easy.
If Iâm not swimming as hard as I can, feet thrashing at the waves, Iâm drowning.
Henry is waiting for me outside the classroom.
This, in itself, is not unusual. I canât pinpoint when exactly it started, but Henry and I have gotten into the habit of walking to our classes together. Itâs a simple matter of practicality. Necessity. We share the same classes for almost every subject, after allâa fact I used to deeply resentâand we always put those extra four or five minutes to good use, strategizing and fine-tuning and outlining the next Beijing Ghost tasks under our breaths as we walk. Sometimes Iâll even pull out my planner, or a clipboard.
But somethingâs different today.
I notice it in the way Henry looks at me when I walk out, the way he flinches as I draw near. Itâs such an odd sight Iâm almost convinced Iâve imagined it. I donât think Iâve ever seen Henry Li flinch before.
Yet even odder is the expression that settles over his features like a shadow:
Concern.
Concern for me, because⦠I was hyperventilating during our test just now? Because itâs clear Iâve been crying? Because he overheard my conversation with Mr. Murphy?
There are so many possibilities. All of them make me want to run far away in the opposite direction.
But before I can turn around, he steps toward me.
âYou forgot about the test,â he says. Not are you okay? or how did it go? or do you want to talk about it? Maybe he isnât that concerned after all.
I run my tongue over the sharp edges of my teeth. âYeah, I know. And I swear, if youâre going to rub it inââ
âNo,â he says. Quickly. âThat was not my intention.â
And even though itâs the last thing Iâd expect myself to do, especially when I still feel like my world is about to end, I canât help it: I snort.
He frowns. âIs something funny?â
âNo, no, nothing,â I say, shaking my headâthen stop abruptly, when the motion makes pain spike through my skull. At this rate, I canât even tell if the migraine is from sleep deprivation or from bawling my eyes out.
Henry says nothing, but his frown deepens.
âOkay, fine, you really want to know? Itâs justâyou just sound so posh all the time, oh my god.â I straighten my posture to match his and mimic him with an exaggerated British accent. âThat was not my intention.â
âI do not sound like that,â he says, affronted.
âYouâre right. You sound even posher. Why are you still here, anyway?â I ask, looking over his shoulder to scan the emptying hall. âShouldnât we be getting to class orââ
âEnglish is canceled for the day. Mr. Chen was invited to deliver a lecture at Peking University.â He hesitates. âThe email came a few minutes ago, when you wereâ¦â
When I was having a mental breakdown.
âAh,â I say, suddenly far too aware of the damp patches on my blazer from when I used it to wipe my face. The puffiness in my lips and cheeks. The dry, uncomfortable ache in my eyes. I turn my head, feigning interest in the glass display to my left. Glossy certificates catch the artificial light of the hall, the golden, italicized text gleaming like magic:Â Rachel Kim: First Place in IGCSE History. Patricia Chao: Best All-Rounder Award. Isabella Lee: Perfect Score in IB Geography.
All legends. All names that continue to adorn our halls, remind us of their greatness, long after the students themselves have graduated.
The sound of crinkling paper pulls me from my thoughts. I glance back to see Henry reaching for something in his bag. âDo you wantââ
âOh, itâs fine, I can just get some from the bathroom,â I say, assuming heâs about to offer me a tissue.
But then heâs holding up one of those White Rabbit milk candies I saw him eating in his dorm, the creamy white wrapper smooth, almost the same shade as his outstretched palm. Confusion flickers over his features when he hears the end of my sentence.
We both pause. Catch our mistake.
God, why does everything have to be so awkward when Iâm around him?
âUh. Never mind.â I hold out my hand. âGuess I could do with some candy.â As he passes it over, his fingers brush against mine. Just once, briefly, there and then gone. So warm and light they could be confused for the flutter of birdsâ wings.
It feels nice. Too nice.
I retract my hand as if Iâve been burnt.
âThanks,â I mumble, busying myself with peeling the wrapper and bringing the candy to my lips. Immediately, the thin, papery outer layer melts on my tongue, and the rich, mildly sweet taste fills my mouth.
It tastes like my childhood. Like the long, luxurious summers in Beijing before I left for America, before my nainai passed away. Mama rarely let me have sweets, saying it was a waste of money and bad for my teeth, but every morning during the holidays, Nainai would hobble out to the local grocery store and buy little packets of White Rabbit milk candy, hiding them inside her handkerchief. Whenever Mama wasnât looking, she would sneak one to me with a wink.
But my memories of her more or less end there.
She only called on my birthdays after we moved across the sea, said she didnât want to inconvenience us as we tried to settle in, that she knew we were busy. Then, sometime after I turned nine, she died alone at home. A stroke. Preventable, if only she had the money to pay for a proper checkup and medical treatment, to ask for help when she wasnât feeling well.
Baba and Mama didnât even tell me she was gone until the day of the Qingming Festival.
My throat burns at the thought, at the injustice of it all, but this time, at least, I manage to force the tears back before they can form.
I donât know why Iâm so emotional today.
I sneak a quick glance at Henry to see if heâs noticed, but he seems suddenly fascinated by the awards display too.
âItâs been ages since I last had one of these,â I say, more to break the awkward silence than anything. âThey were my favorite childhood treat.â
He turns to face me, his expression impassive. âMine too.â He says this almost reluctantly, with great caution, like heâs disclosing some kind of confidential business information. âMy mother used to give me one whenever I had a bad day at school.â
âReally?â Surprise leaks into my voice, and not just because I canât imagine him ever having a bad day at school. Not even a subpar day. âI thought youâd have grown up eating all that fancy, expensive stuff.â
His eyebrows arch. âFancy, expensive stuff?â
âYou know what I mean,â I say, annoyed. I recall the lavish feast spread out before Chanelâs father and the young woman, the delicacies arranged in their clay bowls and tiny crystal plates. The food of emperors, of kings. âLike birdâs nest soup or sea cucumber or something.â As soon as the words come out of my mouth, I realize how ignorant I must sound. How painfully obvious it must be to Henry that we were raised in two separate worlds, that Iâve only witnessed but never experienced the casual luxuries he must take for granted in his life.
I wonder if he feels sorry for me, and anticipatory anger rattles in my stomach like a snake as I imagine him tiptoeing around the subject, trying to play down the obvious discrepancies between our childhoods: They werenât that expensive, or We only had those once a week.
But in reality, he just shrugs one shoulder and says, âI never really liked sea cucumber, actually. They used to creep me out when I was a kid.â
âYeah, well, they do look a bit like slugs,â I mutter, and he laughs.
I stare at him, taken aback by how his entire demeanour seems to change: the sharp, regal lines of his face softening, white teeth flashing, his shoulders slipping forward from their usual stiff posture. Heâs so closed off all the time that I didnât even think Henry was capable of laughing. For a moment I wonder what we might look like from an outsiderâs perspective: just two teenagers joking around and sharing candy and chatting together after class. Friends, maybe. The thought startles me.
Then Henry catches me staring, registers the visible shock on my face, and sobers up at once, like heâs been caught doing something he shouldnât. The curve of his ears turn pink slightly.
âWell, anyway.â He slides his hands into his blazer pockets. âI should probably go. Study. Our midterms are soon.â
âOh. Okay.â
But he makes no immediate move to leave. âWill you be all right? Afterâ¦â He trails off, once again leaving it to me to fill out the rest of his sentence. âEither way, itâs not as if a bad grade would bring your average down so much, right? So long as you do well in the midterms, you could still be ranked second in the class.â
I bristle, the remnants of that brief, tender moment we shared earlier vanishing like smoke. Weâre not friends, I remind myself. Weâre competitors. Enemies. Only one of us can win in the end.
âI donât want to be ranked second.â I surge forward until Iâm standing right in front of him, hating that I have to crane my neck just so weâre at eye level. âIf Iâm not first, Iâm nothing.â
He merely looks amused. âIs there really such a substantial difference? I doubt your report cardââ
âItâs not just about how my report card looks,â I interrupt. âItâs about losing my winning streak with the Academic Award next year. Itâs about what people will think of me.â
âIt doesnât matter what people thinkââ
âBullshit,â I say hotly. âThatâs bullshit, and you know it. Perception is everything. Money would just be colored paper if we didnât all think it was important.â
âCotton, actually.â
âWhat?â
âContrary to popular belief, money is mostly made out of cotton,â he says, as if this is life-changing information. âJust thought youâd want to know. But do go on.â
The idea of murdering him flits through my mind.
âMy point is,â I say through gritted teeth, âwhen a large enough number of people collectively care enough about somethingâno matter how superficial or arbitrary or inherently worthless it isâit starts to carry value. Itâs like when people say it doesnât matter where you get your education, but watch how fast they change their attitude, their tone when you tell them you go to Airington.â I suck in a breath, curl my trembling hands into fists. âEven just now. Mr. Murphy was already looking at me differently because Iââ I swallow. âBecause I fucked up on that one test.â
Surprise flashes across Henryâs face. I donât think anyone at Airington has ever heard me swear out loud before. Itâs kind of liberating, really. Cathartic. It even makes me feel a little betterâ
Until one of the classroom doors down the hall swings open, and Julie Walsh steps out.
Her narrowed eyes instantly land on me, and she comes marching straight over, thin heels clacking, sleek blond hair bobbing with every step, her lips pressed into a tight line. As she draws closer, the strong, sickly sweet scent of her perfume hits my nose. I try not to choke.
âSuch foul language,â she hisses, shaking her head. âHonestly, after everything weâve taught you here at Airington, is this really how you wish to conduct yourself?â
A mixture of embarrassment and annoyance snake under my skin. Iâm tempted to tell her about the number of Chinese and Korean swear words students have used right in front of her face in the past week alone, but because I still have somewhat of a will to liveâand because Iâd never throw the other kids under the bus like thatâI decide against it.
âSorry, Juââ I catch myself just in time. âDr. Walsh.â
âHmph. You certainly should be.â She sniffs. âDonât let me catch you swearing again, Vanessa Liu, or there will be consequences.â
I look up at her, stunned. Like Mr. Murphy, sheâs been teaching me for five yearsâsurely she must know who I am? My name, at least? Besides, Vanessa and I donât even look remotely alike; her face is sharp and long whereas mine is wide, her nose petite while mine is round, and her skin is at least five shades paler thanks to all her Korean skincare products. Anyone with eyes should be able to tell the difference between us.
I wait for Julie to realize her mistake, to correct herself.
She doesnât.
Just stares me down with those cold blue eyes like she expects me to apologize again.
But instead, all I say is, âItâs Alice.â
Her face goes blank with confusion. âWhat?â
âIÂ said, my name is Alice. Not Vanessa.â
âHuh. Is it now?â she finally says, unconvinced, looking for a second as if she actually believes I mightâve mixed up my own name. When I nod, she gives me a tight-lipped smile that isnât much friendlier than a glare. âWell, pardon me, Alice. But my earlier point still stands, of course.â
âOf course,â I echo.
Satisfied, she spins around on her noisy heels and leaves. As soon as sheâs out of earshot, Henry mutters, âCharming, isnât she?â
On this, at least, we can agree.